Boy doesn't it! Which is why I think I will get clear doors, then I would have noticed the problem sooner. I do not open the doors all that often, only to add water. I just go down, check the gauges and come back up. With clear doors I would have seen they were not moving.
I am glad to see you think the lack of turning most likely caused the mess too. I had heard not turning the eggs would make for a bad hatch. I know that now.
Thanks for the sympathy..
BTW what do you think I should do with Ethel, the other 2 hens now and the stolen eggs? Should I move them and give them other eggs? Or just move them and make them lay new ones?
You know your "boss" hen better than I do and so do your younger hens. Let Ethel do what she wants to and try to relocate the other 2. Just relocating them to another pen may get them laying again but if they have already been broody, they will need to be exposed to a tom again to get fertile eggs.
It really isn't that hard to cut a section out of your current doors and glue a piece of plexiglass on each side of the hole in the door. It is by far less expensive than buying a replacement door.