Advice needed - adding a chicken or chick to the flock?

Hi, sorry to hear about your lost hen. Don't worry about your other girls, they'll get over her in no time.
This is what I've found about introducing new stock to my flock. Introducing at least 2 at the same time helps. They at least have each other they recognize. I usually use the coop inside the coop technique. I put a dog cage inside the coop and pen the new comers inside for a period of time until they seem comfortable and everybody is used to everybody. Usually a week to 2 weeks. Feed and water sep.
Now in your situation, sounds like a small coop, maybe without room to coop inside it with cage, so I would for sure get 2 so they will have some comfort. But thats just me.
About the age question, remember if you get older hens, they will establish pecking order over your current girls, or at least try to. resulting in small fights. I have always found it easier to introduce the younger ones.
Well hope I made some sense, and good luck. I find it hard to believe that you think your gonna be happy with only 4 chickens...hehehe we'll see. You should have built a much bigger coop. lol

 

I totally agree with Robin. I would add two and if you can keep them in a small area inside pen to let others get used to them it helps.

 

I have heard that its best to keep an "even" number of chooks so 4 is best??
When I introduce new chickens I always buy 2 then I keep them separate for the first night and in the morning I let the new ones roam the yard to get to know the place, water and food location etc. while the others are still locked up. then I let the olders out and yes they squabble but settle down in a couple of days.
Its only when the newbies try to outrank the oldies that they get picked on.
If the newbies are well behaved they should have no probs. younger chooks may be good for personality training!!
good luck
Helen

 

Definitely 2 or more at a time. I added 3 new chicks - old enough to be outside- to my 2 older hens after one of my big hens died using the keep them separate but close method. They have done fine. I had one little banty fly into my yard and was never accepted though they did tolerate her out free-ranging in the yard but pecked her badly in their run even after knowing her for a year. I usually like to get 3 of most baby things in case one dies they still have each other - that's my thinking.

 

I'm so sorry!