Am I being unreasonable?

australorpchick

Songster
10 Years
Joined
Feb 18, 2009
Messages
903
Reaction score
5
Points
141
Location
Canyon Lake, TX
WARNING this is going to be long-winded.

Next year MIL turns 90. She has decided to throw a birthday party for herself. Except it's not really a birthday party, it's more like a thank you party for any person that has vaguely helped her in one form or the other. People that she's volunteered with, people who work at her Dr.'s office, etc. She wants it either at the church hall or at a golf course.

DH wants to go. No problem, I'd never tell him he couldn't visit his family. DH wants the kids to go. Slight problem, but I'm okay if the kids want to go. DH wants me to go. Now we have a problem.

I was the driving force behind our move from San Diego to Texas. I couldn't stand it there anymore. It was so crowded, so hectic, so expensive and kids over there were growing up too fast. My husband and I worked different schedules for 11 years. He worked all of the holidays and he might have had one Saturday off every other month. We mainly saw each other at night. I was miserable. Also, somehow I knew, that we were going to be in for a world of financial hurt if we stayed. We were barely making it and we were both working full-time, making decent money. I knew we'd have to buy at least one car in the near future. Turned out I was right. If we had stayed, our mortgage would be under water right now. Our once middle-class neighborhood, now has a homeless camp on the field at the end of our street. I am a native San Diegan, but San Diego no longer felt like home.

We moved to Texas in Aug. 2006. Since then my MIL has visited us once and that's only because I had an absolute fit when I found out she was flying into San Antonio to go to Kingsville for a couple months and had no intention on visiting her son or gkids
somad.gif
(which by the way she swore up and down, she would miss soooo much when we moved). She ended up staying for a couple of nights, to which she proceeded to ignore her son, sleep across my reclining sofa (pet peeve of mine) and over ate, which resulted in her almost puking in my beloved Suburban
sickbyc.gif
. The next time she went to Kingsville, my husband had to drive there to visit her.

Since we moved to Texas in 2006, DH went there by himself in 2007 and despite my displeasure, we spent our family vacation there in 2008. I declared 2009 to be a "no big vacation" year, so that we could build up our savings. In between and after those visits, my nieces, BIL#4 and BIL#1 & SIL have come to visit us.

While I love spending time with my nieces, BIL's & SIL's, I have no desire to vacation where I spent 30 years of my life and intentionally left. It's not cheap to fly all 4 of us out there, at least $1,200. If we do go, this will be the 2nd vacation to SD, out of the 3 vacations we'll have taken. There are so many other places DH, DDs and I would like to go. BIL#1 & SIL really want to go somewhere with us, which I'd love, but we can only afford to do one expensive vacation a year.

Oh yeah...did I mention that MIL wants me to cook & bake for the party!
th.gif


I've told DH that I really don't want to go and the only way I will go is if we go somewhere else while we're there. Here are my ideas so far 1)Disneyland, Knotts Berry Farm & Universal Studios, 2) rent a cabin at June Lake or Yosemite, 3) visit Tombstone and the Grand Canyon or 4) Maui. I also informed him that no way in heck will I be cooking.

Am I being unreasonable?
 
No, if you have to use your vacation time and money and if your relationship with MIL isnt super then she shouldnt expect you to cook and I dont know how she felt ok ASKING. If she really 90 tho, that generation can be a little different in the way they communicate. They come across as demanding to the rest of us but thats just them...they mean no harm
 
No I don't think you're being unreasonable.

I was raised by a Southern Lady and there's so much about your MIL attitude that rubs me the wrong way, but
duc.gif


Let me just say, with the tone she's going for with this party - inviting near strangers and holding it at a club/church, she REALLY needs to have it professionally catered or look like a very poor hostess. Pot lucks are for Boy Scouts and close friends and family.

I do think you should go because it's probably her "last hurrah," seeing that she's 90 and all. Time your arrival to the day before the party, so you miss most of the prep time. Go to the party, so you've gotten that out of the way. Then spend the rest of the week doing fun activities with your DH and kids. I think that is a VERY reasonable comprimise.

I did that with my brother's wedding - none of us approved of the dictator he married and I was so upset over the insanity of their demands/actions pre-wedding that I timed my cross-country flight to arrive right before the rehersal dinner, attending the wedding, smiled for pictures, waved them on their honeymoon and enjoyed the rest of the week visiting Sedona, the Grand Canyon and shopping with my family.
big_smile.png
It was a really nice trip!
 
I agree with Southernbelle, too. It is a big family deal; you should go. As for cooking, it is one thing if you have a particularly fabulous dish that is a special request. Otherwise, she is throwing herself a party that is not just family and close friends so she should be in charge of catering. Be gracious and smile and then have a mai tai on Maui.
 
Well..you may not like what i have to say..(and i'm sorry if you dont..because i truly dont want to offend...
hugs.gif
)

I say, cut the lady some slack, shes 90 for crying out loud. Whats she gonna live maybe another 5 years or something? My grandmother is going to be 96 this October and we're all praying she can make it that long. Her kidneys are failing, and her CHF is smothering her day by day. I say be nice. She'll be gone soon and your husband wont have his mother anymore and your kids their gradmother. As for the cooking, i'd have the rest of the family help you out.
 
Last edited:
So far I'm very lucky and have a good relationship with my son and daughters in law. I pray that continues into the future. I would hope that even if we would have a falling out sometime in the next 34 years (that's how long till I hit 90!) they could put whatever they're upset about aside long enough to come visit and celebrate with me.

So yes, my opinion is that you're being unreasonable...go to the celebration with your husband and kids and have a positive attitude that you'll have a good time.
 
I agree that you need to go... you got your "No vacation 2009" does the rest of your family agree with you? It is your husband's mother and she isnt getting any younger. Sorry if I'm offending but all I heard in your post was
"I want this, I moved us here, etc... etc.... " Make your decision based on what is best for your family... not just you. It sounds like they want you there.

As for cooking for the party.. if you don't want to .. don't. If you do , maybe your MIL can pitch in for your ticket since she's getting a free caterer?


Good luck!


Nancy
 
Last edited:

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom