Am I wrong to ask ext. family NOT to exchange Ch. gifts?

Quote:
this.

you might try this to make it a little less awkward...
after she gives you the gift, open it, apprecaite and oo and aw over it, give her a big hug, look her sincerely in the eyes and say "I think it's really lovely that you still went to all this trouble even though you know we can't reciprocate!"
if that's not enough, you can say "you're always such a generous person, its one of the wonderful things about you."

....

when people insist on giving when you have asked them not to, there are several reasons that might happen...

1) they really like doing it and don't care if you give them anything back. ok, so appreciate them for thier effort, and don't worry about it.

2) they feel obligated and would feel guilty if they didn't. what you're giving them with your appreciation is relief from guilt... not a bad present.

3) they're trying to guilt you into giving gifts you can't afford. sweet appreciation and a pleasant attitude, along with a firm adherance to your position is a fine way of managing an attempted guilt trip.

4) they're trying to show you how much better they are than you. same solution as #3... this is a game I just won't participate in, and by not being bothered and maintaining my happy attitude and gracious appreciation without obligation I can halt the game in it's tracks. most folks who want to play this game require an opponent. since I won't play, usually they find someone else who will and stop bothering me with it.


------

when we're strapped, and I really want to give something, I find something I can give that has my time in it instead of my money. a jar with a special hot chocolate mix, or a special cookie mix in it, with all the ingredients layred like sand art, and a pretty square of cloth over the lid with a ribbon, and a printed set of instructions tied to the top. a hand-painted christmas ornament. a card with a story from our mutual history that is a favorite memory of mine about them.
 
I always buy for the kids... not adults though.
I have cousins that i only see like once a year also.. but they look forward to seeing us and our family gathering at christmas... so i try to get them each something to open.
They are only kids for such a short time..
 
Last edited:
Quote:
Since you are in such financial hardship.. your brother should have respected your wish. But WHEN did you tell him to not buy gifts?? Maybe he already got them??
Maybe he doesnt care if you return the gift favor... he just wants to get you all something because he cares and because he can...?
Can you make his kids a gift?? Homemade things are usually soooo much better than bought anyways... i know that i REALLY appreciate them more!

How many kids does he have??
 
Last edited:
Quote:
If you will be with them for Christmas, write a story that you read to them all. It's about how loving, caring children gave up Christmas to help their cousins. You can make it about saving their cousins' house and embellish the crap out of it, or make it slightly less personal, but still get the message. Then give them all something small and handmade that shows lots of love, hand made cards, or something.
 
We quit with that gift giving stuff. We buy for our two kids, that is it. Were usually broke and see no reason to put financial strain on our family so someone can get a gift they won't even remember by the end of the night. Seriously.
roll.png
 
Quote:
x2!! And if their kids have as much as you've suggested, then their kids certainly aren't going to pay attention to not getting another one. I know when my mom was having a tough time financially, she didn't buy for anyone, including the grandkids (my brother and I only have one child each - so only 2 grandkids). My son paid absolutely no attention, and I'm sure my nephew didn't either.
 
This whole "not giving gifts thing" started a family feud three years ago that has ruined the most wonderful time of the year for me. I hope your family handles this challange better than mine did. There's a lot of really good suggestions here, maybe one will help me too.


KimberlyJ ~Good Luck
 
Last edited:
Quote:
Since you are in such financial hardship.. your brother should have respected your wish. But WHEN did you tell him to not buy gifts?? Maybe he already got them??
Maybe he doesnt care if you return the gift favor... he just wants to get you all something because he cares and because he can...?
Can you make his kids a gift?? Homemade things are usually soooo much better than bought anyways... i know that i REALLY appreciate them more!

How many kids does he have??

He has only 3 children, but there is also my Aunt and Uncle, the two of them, my sister and her two children. 12 in all if I count right. I love the idea of a homemade gift, and I really just need to get over my wounded pride. I told them 3 months ago, I thought it was enough time. Thanks for all the ideas and replies. Henz
 
Quote:
Kim, I am so afraid this will happen here too. We have a very very nice house, but I have been unemployed for over a year, that is the hardest part. So, I am sure they think we are loaded, but we are 3 months behind on the mortgage and that equals over 10K. If I get re-employed, we can eventually catch up, I hope. If, a big big IF. This site always makes me feel better.
 
Quote:
people fued over some of the stupidest things... especially during a time which should bring familys closer together. we haven't had that, but I think if it was headed that way, I'd want to sit down with them for a chat, explain again that we don't have the funds (no need for details) and ask if they really want christmas to be all about feuding or about family connections and time together? ask if they really think that it's about money and stuff, and if they really want to put that before family and spirituality? sometimes folks can see it more clearly when it's all down on the table that way. and if they can't, if they're really the sorts of people who think parity in gift giving is paramount, and that they'd rather be angry over imagined slights and loose family, that the gifts are worth going to war over with folks you love, well... I guess I'd have to kiss them on the forehead, give them a nice hug, tell them they're welcome back if they change their minds and send them out my door.

sadly, being related to someone is no guarantee that we'll share the same values. if they don't, that's ok, it just may mean I have to seek my close relationships and spend my holiday time elsewhere.
 
Last edited:

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom