Interesting. How can you tell the difference? They were sold as americaunas. Not a big deal, they are only here as pets and to put eggs in my fridge. Do the eaater eggers get the beard and muff as well? The grey one has them starting but not so much on the peach girl.
What is really obvious is the color. Ameraucanas only come in 8 recognized colors. Black, Blue, Blue Wheaten, Wheaten, Brown Red, Silver, White and Buff. There are a few project colors in the works, Lavender is one I know about. I think they are also working on Cuckoo.. but I don't know what else is out there. These are not recognized colors but breeders are working on perfecting them to get them accepted. The rule is that they have to breed true 50% of the time. Mixing colors means they don't breed true - so mixed colors are not accepted. They are called Easter Eggers.
The ones from the Feed stores and Hatcheries are also called Easter Eggers on this site, but those birds have probably been mixed with other breeds - most likely Leghorn - and they usually do not look like the Ameraucanas. The feed stores and hatcheries call them Americanas, Ameraucanas or Aracaunas (sp?) and unfortunately this just confuses people. They also can lay brown, tan, white or dark green eggs. The hatcheries and feed stores usually don't care about egg color, body color, body shape, etc - all they care about is volume and healthy chicks they can sell.
Yes, Easter Eggers get beards, and lay blue eggs, and are really neat chickens. Come join us over here: https://www.backyardchickens.com/t/273489/the-ee-braggers-thread/12070#post_11635262 and see all the pretty colors they come in.
Last edited: