Ok, did a 5 day candle of my Sunday set, and it's confirmed. I have a gorgeous black rooster that is 0% fertile in 75 degree weather. The splash is still 95%, and the girls all came from the same batch, so it's not the girls. I've wasted space in the incubator for the last time. I have a gorgeous black rooster that won't reproduce. Now I have a dilemma, and 3 options:
1. Leave the black with those girls and wait 6 more months until I can replace him with a blue from the splash pen, basically ruining my whole year with 4 laying hens.
2. Put those light blue and splash hens in with the splash rooster, and get more chicks, but take the chance of diluting those blues even further.
3. Take my blue rooster with the leakage, put him with the light blues, and hope he produces a non-leaky black to replace him this year.
Trimming feathers is not an option for me. I'm not manscaping a bird just to see if it will work when his brother is 95%. He's getting on the girls, I've seen it. He's either infertile, or has horrible aim. He won't reproduce, so he has to go. It's a shame, because he's the closest to SOP I have.
My blue rooster is gorgeous. He's the biggest, most well shaped rooster of the 3. He was the alpha before the pen split, and is currently in an OE pen with BCM culls. For those of you that don't know, my issue with him was leaky shoulder feathers, and that's why he was put in the OE pen.
Someone once told me to build the barn before I paint it. Do I put this big blue in with the girls, keep all the cockerels and grow them out to see who leaks and who doesn't, then hopefully get a non-leaky blue or black to take his place? If I do that, am I compromising the females by breeding carriers? What would you guys do?
Oh boy...that is rough. I sure hate that.
As to your options, I would put the girls in with the splash rooster, then take those chicks back to black next year. I wouldn't use the rooster with the leakage - even if you don't see it in the first generation, it will haunt you down the road.
PS - check your ovations

That would be my choice.

Last edited: