I'm probably lost in the conversation somewhere and maybe it was in reference to a particular variety or maybe a project being worked on but even then it still doesn't make much sense to me. Why would one get rid of both parents just because a sport happened to appear?
My first thought is that if one is line-breeding and keeping good records, there should be no question as to which parent is doing what. My second thought is why get rid of two otherwise very good birds (assuming that is the case) just because one or both of them happens to throw an odd chick say 1 out of a 100 times?
For example, I breed and show the WBS variety. Out of 75 or more chicks hatched last year, I had 3 Wheatens that were sort of mottled. Meaning they had large black splotches throughout their plumage. I inquired about this both on here and the ABC forum and never really got anything more than "it happens sometimes". So I chocked it up to just one of those genetic things that will happen from time to time. My point is, if 99.5% of the other offspring is good, why toss the parents because of the .5%???
Now, if one is flock breeding and the parentage is unknown, that would be a different story. Just another reason why I recommend line-breeding and keeping meticulous records.
God Bless,