American Idol

[texasgal]

Quote:
And just when I was really impressed...........................

I love your def of Pia .. I feel the same way ..

And James has ALWAYS been my fav .. I liked him from the get-go .. but his Judas Priest freakin' rocked my world .. and then pulling off Paul McCartney .. *sigh*

 

[coloradochick]

No, I agree with you, but I guess what I'm trying to say is, Casey sings good (I guess) for what he sings but can you see him actually having a career doing what he does. I can't. So I think he needs to go

along with Niaima.

 

[texasgal]

Quote:
yes.

You can't because you don't appreciate that kind of music .. (not being ugly ..

) .. and that's ok. I bet you've never bought a jazz CD or gone to a jazz concert either..

and I do think that is what is hurting him .. fewer people recognize his talent in that genre, than say Scotty's voice, or James' rock star quality ... but it doesn't make it any less real.

Casey will do just fine .. imo

 

[Laurajean]

Quote:
And just when I was really impressed...........................

I love your def of Pia .. I feel the same way ..

And James has ALWAYS been my fav .. I liked him from the get-go .. but his Judas Priest freakin' rocked my world .. and then pulling off Paul McCartney .. *sigh*

That's why we always get along so well Texasgal, great minds think alike!

(And yes, I had to look up all the names, sue me. If I didn't it would have been "scruffy guy" this and that, "girl with deep set eyes", "Rod Steward Guy", "No personality Girl with Good Voice", etc.

 

[texasgal]

Quote:
And just when I was really impressed...........................

I love your def of Pia .. I feel the same way ..

And James has ALWAYS been my fav .. I liked him from the get-go .. but his Judas Priest freakin' rocked my world .. and then pulling off Paul McCartney .. *sigh*

That's why we always get along so well Texasgal, great minds think alike!

(And yes, I had to look up all the names, sue me. If I didn't it would have been "scruffy guy" this and that, "girl with deep set eyes", "Rod Steward Guy", "No personality Girl with Good Voice", etc.

Let's see .. for the first couple of weeks it was:

bearded jazzy guy
white smile guy
black gospel singer-ish guy
country guy
tourettes rocker dude

etc ..

I'm right there with ya girl!

 

[Laurajean]

Quote:
That's why we always get along so well Texasgal, great minds think alike!

(And yes, I had to look up all the names, sue me. If I didn't it would have been "scruffy guy" this and that, "girl with deep set eyes", "Rod Steward Guy", "No personality Girl with Good Voice", etc.

Let's see .. for the first couple of weeks it was:

bearded jazzy guy
white smile guy
black gospel singer-ish guy
country guy
tourettes rocker dude

etc ..

I'm right there with ya girl!

EXACTLY! We really do think alike.

 

[thechickenchick]

This season is just sooo good! I realy don't believe Casey was putting on an act. I mean the poor guy looked like he was going to pass out or vomit on Ryans shoes. He is a singer, not an actor!

His style isn't my taste, but there is no doubt the kid has talent and charisma. James Is my personal favorite

 

[Robin'sBrood]

No, I don't think Casey knew it, but I think the producers had it staged.

 

[Winggedheart]

I don't think so; it seemed rather like a bunch of bad luck. He doesn't deserve to be out, at least---not yet. I think that what with his screamy work on the Nirvana song he just didn't get many votes.

 

[Winggedheart]

He did MUCH better this last show, though.