American Idol

[teach1rusl]

Hmmmm....not liking this week's performances as much as last weeks

 

[Robin'sBrood]

Really? I thought most of them did great tonight!

 

[jennh]

I still say Pia needs to show some emotion. Sure, she can sing, has a BEAUTIFUL voice. I just think she looks so smug. I think Thia and Naimi sp? are gonna go.

 

[Kbagwell1]

Quote:
I agree 100%! But I kinda feel like Stephano may go...I dunno, guess we'll have to wait and see!

 

[Laurajean]

Quote:
I agree 100%! But I kinda feel like Stephano may go...I dunno, guess we'll have to wait and see!

Good call on both above posts. I think Pia has the personality of shirt cardboard. I don't care how well she can sing, she looks conceited and bores the heck out of me. I also don't see what the big deal with Stefano is. I don't think he's that talented.

I think Thia sings nice, but she's just not a thrill; she belongs in a quaint disney movie or a musical. Naimi tries too hard to be unique. If you have to try that hard, you probably aren't the real thing, sorry.

I didn't care for Casey, and was dumbfounded last week when they saved him. Then he actually shocked me tonight by SINGING.

My favorite: James! He has it all, talented, puts on a great performance and seems like a good, genuine guy. I've been rooting for him since the beginning.

 

[flowerchicks]

I really like Thia, but I agree that her voice is very "disney". I do prefer it to Pia, though. I think Casey did much better this week, and James Durbin is definitely talented! My favorite is Haley. I love her style and voice, but I tonights performance wasn't my favorite... could be because I don't like the song

I want to see Naima go, for sure! I think the other one will be Stefano or Thia

edited for bad spelling

 

[flowerchicks]

Oh, and Paul Mcdonald is sooooooooo annoying

talk about a "one trick pony"...

 

[Winggedheart]

I thought everybody did pretty good; Lauren did better this time, I keep telling my mom she needs to stick to slower stuff instead of things like Reba and S Twain.

 

[texasgal]

Steven summed Haley up pretty well .. YOU.SING.SEXY ... I really LOVE her...

I'm still all about James, but I think he's safe, so all my votes went to Casey (we don't think COMPLETELY alike laurajean .. lol)


Thia was good last night .. but I think she needs to mature ..

I love love love Elton John, so it was REALLY hard for any of them to knock my socks off.. lol.

I think Pia probably did the best job singing .. but ... B.O.R.I.N.G ..

 

[Kbagwell1]

Quote:
I agree with you! Can't wait to see what happens tonight! Its gonna be a heck of a night....I have a feeling it'll be between Stephano, Thia, and Niama. What do yall think?