American Idol

[jennh]

Well, I think I should change my views and play the lottery after all. I have hit each one on the head. I somehow figured it would be Casey. Yay!!!! No more growling!

 

[bakerjw]

I would have put money on a James and Casey final. Now I'll have to go with James and Scotty. And definitely Jacob needs to go. He started off with a humble attitude but I think that it was just an act.

But Casey was probably the most talented and versatile person that they've had on in a long while. He'll be cutting a jazz album real soon and it will likely do very well. We hated to see him go.

 

[justuschickens59]

Well, I'm disappointed that Casey is gone - I'll miss hearing him every week, and I'll miss the duets with him and Haley - but...I figure it is probably better for him to have gone now. I think he will have much more creative license than if he had won the whole thing. Some good examples of that are Adam Lambert, Chris Daughtry, and Jennifer Hudson. Casey definitely is one of the most talented musicians they have ever had on the show - he can do it all - and what a wonderful personality he has. I LOVED his "going out" performance. He is a special young man and I"m happy that we've been able to have been entertained by him these last few months.

I'll be fine with anybody that wins as long as it isn't Jacob. I've never liked his singing, I can't bear to watch him sing. At first, I thought he was a nice young man - but over the weeks, I've definitely changed my mind...I think it was all an act - he definitely thinks he is "ALL THAT."

Anyway - I'm happy for Casey - I think he'll have a wonderful career in whatever he chooses to do, but I will miss seeing him for the next few weeks.

 

[chickensioux]

I liked Casey too and can't see why it was him. He is talented and much more enjoyable to watch than Jacob or Lauren. They are all talented but some are annoying to watch. To each his own.

 

[SundownWaterfowl]

Didn't care for Casey too much, but I would have rather had Jacob go first. I can't stand that guys voice.

 

[sourland]

Like Jacob's voice, but something about him just doesn't seem to ring true.

 

[Robin'sBrood]

Jacob is "singing" (screeching) and my ears are bleeding!

That second song was SOOOOOOOOOOOOO bad, yet the judges are all falling all over themselves over it. I don't get it...

 

[NellaBean]

Yep, still don't like him.

 

[Laurajean]

I know. When I heard he was going to sing that song, I cringed. He killed it, and not in a good way.

 

[coloradochick]

Ok just watched Jacob's aka screecher, first song, and it stunk. I think. So for you to say his second song is bad really makes me cringe. And Jennifer needs to back off of Randy. Enough already I wanted her to hear me yelling through my tv

Looks like were both doing some cringing at the same time Laurajean

and I also didn't think that the first guy(can't even think of his name) sang his best tonight either.