American Idol

[sourland]

Hope the West coast isn't reading this.

I PM'd the info to SONEW.

 

[sgtmom52]

Quote:

West Coast is going to be upset. They don't know the outcome yet.

Oops

Sorry ~ but they should be aware that it could show up here and not look at this thread if they don't want to know before watching.

I'll edit mine ~ you have to edit yours too!

 

[Rare Feathers Farm]

HA! Spoiled it for me! Honestly I was HOPING that was the case...I couldn't stand that broad!

 

[Robin'sBrood]

Did anyone else notice what Randy mouthed right after the elimination was announced? I think he was really, really shocked by it. Ryan kept saying that America needed to vote... well, apparently we did and America's taste isn't the same as the show's judges.

In all seriousness, she has a really good voice but something was said about her performance abilities when all she could do while singing a Tina Turner song was walk around the stage and around the judges...

 

[YYZ]

I like Scott !

I didnt notice was Randy did after the announcement i was preoccupied on here. haha

 

[Rare Feathers Farm]

Scotty and Jacob are my two top favs. DH HATES Scotty. LOL

 

[flowerchicks]

Quote:
I'm in CA and I wouldn't be looking at this if I didn't want to know who went home

. I am glad it was Pia, too. She bores me. Of the bottom 3, I like Stefano best, I think he is getting better. I know Scotty is a favorite, and I REALLY liked him in the auditions, but I am having a really hard time watching him lately. He needs a new act on stage, he seems like he is trying to be somebody famous instead of being himself.

I know he is young, and that will come with experience. I have no doubt he will do just fine in country music.

 

[jennh]

Quote:
X 2 except for the DH, he really doesn't care, or watch.

 

[bakerjw]

And how about that Iggy Pop sideshow of a trainwreck. I love the song "Wild One" but he was off key and almost incoherent. That was not something to behold.

 

[featherbaby]

Quote:
It's pretty sad when the contestants talent and performances are SOOOO much better than the guest stars that are making mega-bucks, isn't it? I was revulsed by the naked torso performance. I'm not a prude about skin, it was just inappropriate in this setting. His singing talent? He must have been better in his youth to have gotten where he is professionally. What happened? Was he always this bad?

I was sorry to see Pia go. I think she had an awesome voice. You're right that she didn't have the stage presence performing, but her talent is clearly vocal. I have to say, Stefano is getting better. He was clearly shocked when Pia was the one to go home.