American Idol

[Missouri chick]

I knew that byc would be addictive, but ya'll,,,,,I got so wrapped up here that I missed the 1st half hour of american idol. I never ever EVER miss an episode. I've watched from the begining years ago. Any other fans out there? Which David do you think will make it? Of course being from Missouri originally I have a soft spot for Cook, but I can't make a decision this year.

 

[suenrob]

DAVID COOK ROCKS!!!!

 

[peruvian_princess]

It was a hard one tonight! I mean David Cook has mad skills but David Archuleta has an amazing voice it is going to be a close one.

 

[4-H chicken mom]

The family likes David Cook.

He is the most entertaining. David A is a good singer but all he sings are slow songs.

 

[pullet2hen]

David Cook! David Cook! David Cook!

 

[speckledhen]

I like them both, but they are very different. I think David Cook is more limited in his style whereas David Archuleta can sing more types of music. Neither is a bad choice. Like 'em both, but DH votes Archuleta. At least this year, they're BOTH talented, rather than in past years when I think we've seen someone get voted the winner who was appalling to me. Dare we say screechy Fantasia? OMGosh, did you see her embarrass herself singing on this year's Idol? Geez.

 

[SpottedCrow]

I like David Cook too! I love rockers.
I liked Jason too...
I was surprised that Syesha went as far...
I liked Carly and Amanda also.

 

[Jolyn]

I think David A is a sweet heart and has a nice voice. David C has a great voice but seems a little cocky to me. I think if it's on talent and not popularity it should be Cook.

 

[Jolyn]

Quote:
Really? I think she has a fabulous voice. I just wish her song choices were better!!!

 

[pips&peeps]

Michael Johns should win...................