American Idol

[Missouri chick]

I've never been so undecided. They both have great qualities in very different ways. Both seem humble and thankful to their fans.

 

[knippk]

I have cheered Archuleta on since the start!!!! He is so talented....and his love for music and how it effects people.....thats what won my vote....Cook is good, but we all know whay his C.D. would sound like.....Archuleta could go in sooo many different derections......nervous about wed. night!!!!! Luv ya David A.

 

[moms_pantry]

They are both good. It is a hard call. I still haven't voted. I am not sure who I'm voting for, but I better make up my mind soon.

 

[beefy]

David Archuletta is the most over-rated singer since Michael Jackson.

His composure is horrendous. if American Idol was an aquarium, David Archuletta would be the dorkfish.

 

[pips&peeps]

I caught me a dorkfish..................

 

[justduckie]

I've made my DH watch this season with me since the beginning and we both agree that while David A. has a beautiful voice, he isn't as marketable as David C. And he is SO YOUNG! No composure, not very good stage presence.....open your eyes David A.! You dorkfish.

You're going to run into the glass.

David C. -- I loved his last song even if it wasn't the right song for tonight. I sang right along with him. Go David Cook!

 

[ilovemychickies]

I LOVE David A. He's wonderful! IMO, he's no dorkfish!

Go David A! Go David A! Go David A!

 

[CarriBrown]

 

[nccountrygirl]

I like David A, he is young but he has a beautiful voice. I still think Carly Smithson should have won.

 

[too much fun]

Both great, but I have to go with the local boy. Go David A.!