So sorry kdwag... you know, some of them are just bullies I guess. Perhaps now, we have to just let them dook it out, and see what transpires. I would say as long as there is no serious blood flowing, flesh tearting/eating perhaps they just have to work it out. If there is the blood flowing, flesh tearing, you have a decision on your hands. We all have different levels of what we can tolerate, and what drives us to tears. When I mentioned in another thread that I couldn't stand the bare spots, and now bare heads some of the girls have due to Dukes rough mating, I got blasted out of the thread by the old timers who thought I was some sort of tree hugging softee. I guess some people chalk that up to a rooster being a rooster, but when I hear there are plenty of roosters that don't pull feathers, and bare their girls backs but still manage to fertilize eggs, I realize I too have a decision on my hands. That combined with his attacking people,, I have a decision on my hands! I think I am realizing what my decision is going to be, but in the meantime, I too am putting up with behaviour I wish I could change. If she were mine, and she ripped up another hen again, I would rehome her. Easier said than done I guess, but try to think about your options. I have started to. I have heard about a woman who has a huge free range farm. Duke sounds like the perfect rooster, he will defend to the death. Maybe that is why I still haven't lost one, he is quite the protector.. a stupid protector, but a protector none the less.
Hang in there honey,, you'll come to the decision, and I am sure it will be the right one for you,
MB
I age with this response. Some chickens are just mean, hopefully she will mellow out for you kdawg.
MB, I am right with ya on the waiting out the rooster thing. The one we have is good enough, but he does give me the stink eye and Needs to be put in his place every now and again. Thing is, since I have my little girls around, if he ever decides to go after one of them, dinner will be his next appointment.