We ordered from MPC in April ... 4 EE, 2 Welsummers, and 2 NHs. All were healthy and active. All survived and all are pullets, as ordered. They are absolutely GORGEOUS birds.
We were so happy that we ordered again a few weeks later. This time 3 Australorps, 1 Partridge Cochin, 1 Silver Laced Wyandotte, 2 White Crested Blue Polish, 2 Speckled Sussex, and 1 EE. All seemed healthy on arrival but one of the polish quickly faded and we lost her.
MPC's customer service was great, sympathetic and helpful. The remaining birds are growing to be really stunning too.
By June it was becoming apparent that we were addicted. Another order was placed. When I called it in, we were on the fence about two breeds. Fortunately, the woman who answered the phone had both and answered questions I had about differences between the two ... with first-hand knowledge. After speaking with her, I easily made a decision and haven't had any regrets ... I love our little chantecler girls!
Losses are VERY sad. However, there has to be tremendous stress in shipping AND if you've studied genetics at all, you know that some individuals just don't thrive, even under the best of circumstances. In my opinion, MCP's track record with us has been spectacular.
My one complaint about MPC has nothing to do with the quality of their birds. Their website still shows a Partridge Chantecler on the page for Buff Chanteclers. They now have a disclaimer at the beginning of their description of the breed, but the photo of the other color variety is still up. As novices, we kept overlooking this breed in our first orders because we already had so many brown birds!