As Cathy said, breed what makes you feel comfortable but always keep an eye on the standard of perfection for the araucana. Remember these are just chickens and don't get too caught up in the pure versus mutts arguments. The end game is a rumpless tufted blue egg layer. How you get there really doesn't matter because the araucana is judged by its phenotype or looks, not its pedigree. It is also not judged by what it produces because, the araucana by nature does not breed true to the standard of perfection. A tailed and tufted bird can produce any of the following variations depending on what it is bred to.I'm confused about something. Smoothmule's top two birds have normal tails. Is that acceptable practice to breed birds with tails? Are they still considered purebred? All this is so new to me.
The collonca - rumpless and cleanfaced, blue egg layer. The Ketro - Tailed and Tufted, blue egg layer. The Collonca De Aretes ( North American Araucana) - rumpless, tufted, and blue egg laying.
Probably the most important thing when breeding the araucana responsibly, is learning where they came from and where they are headed. Get yourself a Standard of Perfection, get a copy of Cathy Brunsons book " Rings on their Ears" and learn as much as you can. Learning a little color genetics doesn't hurt either because it will help you make informed breeding choices.
Lanae