Are any of these breeds incompatible in a mixed flock?

The Barred Plymouth Rocks aren’t a breed I would recommend for a first time chicken owner, let alone in a mixed flock. Same applies to Rhode Island Reds.
Get Domiques instead of the Barred Plymouth Rocks. And you’re missing a white egg laying breed, so get 2 White Leghorns.
Well, I have to disagree about the Barred Rocks. We researched breeds before diving into chickens and selected Barred Rocks especially for their more gentle disposition.

I know that some may have other experiences but our first two flocks we're entirely made up of Barred Rocks. I found them to be gentle with me, which was important because I had never been exposed to raising chickens and was quite tenative about reaching into an occupied box to check for an egg. (The first time I did, I talked to the hen & asked her if I could please check to see if she had an egg. When she stood up, she just watched me slowly reach toward her and practically turned herself upside down looking to see what I was doing.) It is also true that the only hen that ever bit me (repeatedly & hard) was a Barred Rock. She was one of my last Barred Rock girls & just didn't like to be touched. It took me 3 years of working with her to get her to politely exit a box with eggs & I just learned not to fuss with her. I'd have her back in a nano second, as I would with any of my past hens (and roos, for that matter!)

Just like people, you will find different personalities with your chickens. Some will be saucier than others, some will be docile, some standoffish, some smart, some oblivious, some flighty, some moody and everything in between.

It's sometimes about how you raise them that helps to bring out their best temperment traits, too. No matter the flock, you're going to enjoy discovering the different aspects of your flock. And yourself.

One of the things I've come to understand about myself is that without a little chicken time each day, I am a cranky person. There's not much that can't be made better by a little chicken tv!
 
Many people have different individual experiences. For example, i have had horrible luck with Wyandottes and have rehomed 4 or 5 before deciding they’re just not docile enough for my flock. I may try some breeder Wyandottes in the future.

Did you get your Wyandottes from a hatchery? Which one?--(if you don't mind me asking). I'm looking for breeders in my area, but figure I'll have to order from a hatchery in order to get the mix of breeds I'm interested in and for them to grow up together from chicks. I'm fine with Wyandottes being reserved, but I wouldn't want any that were overly aggressive. I understand there will be a pecking order, but I don't want any birds to be seriously bullied/bloodied.
 
Well, I have to disagree about the Barred Rocks. We researched breeds before diving into chickens and selected Barred Rocks especially for their more gentle disposition.

I know that some may have other experiences but our first two flocks we're entirely made up of Barred Rocks. It is also true that the only hen that ever bit me (repeatedly & hard) was a Barred Rock.
Barred Plymouth Rocks are human friendly not chicken friendly. You also had a flock of only Barred Plymouth Rocks not a mixed flock.
 
@Cryss @moniquem added Barred Plymouth Rocks to their mixed flocks and they ultimately rehomed them because they were relentlessly bullying some of the other chickens.
Yes, I did rehome my Barred Rock hens, Fraggle and Petra. With me or family they were fine, no agression, great egg producers, and although the youngest of the flock they were the biggest hens I had. Lovely birds. But they were so domineering over the flock that one of my girls, an EE, hid and ran from them constantly to the point she couldn't come out to eat or drink even with multiple stations. I eventually made Fraggle wear peepers which slowed her down but continued to be relentless. I was fortunate enough to find a home with a fellow BYCer for the BRs and they are very happy, even having a handsome BR rooster in the flock. I am trying to build a gentle non domineering type flock for colorful eggs, fertilizer for my garden, and pets to spoil. I have 1 EE, 2 BO, and 1 SLW that is the best friend to the EE. Pecking order is expected. Bullying is not allowed.
 
Did you get your Wyandottes from a hatchery? Which one?--(if you don't mind me asking). I'm looking for breeders in my area, but figure I'll have to order from a hatchery in order to get the mix of breeds I'm interested in and for them to grow up together from chicks. I'm fine with Wyandottes being reserved, but I wouldn't want any that were overly aggressive. I understand there will be a pecking order, but I don't want any birds to be seriously bullied/bloodied.

I got my Attila from Meyer Hatchery. She's reserved but I've seen zero aggression from her towards other birds - she prefers the flock's company and screams bloody murder if I separate her out to hold her.

This is her refusing to be held or look at the camera, lol.
20190428_144337(0).jpg
 

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom