Great discussion about one of the breeds that is near and dear to my heart. My journey with Houdans started 25 years ago when I was given 6 young Houdan chicks to raise. I had raised them to a couple of months in age and they were looking better when I lost 5 of the 6 unfortunately. BUT, the one that was still around turned out to be a Cockerel. The first year he looked alot like the mish mash of white and black but after his first moult his feathers came in completely different and he was extraordinary. You keep talking about what those Houdans looked like in the standard, well he was a the spitting image of it. Predominantly black with very small white tipped feathers, a large crest(not just the little poof of feathers that half of these have now) and a very prominent V comb. He was exactly what I thought a Houdan should be honestly, and he weighed a good solid 8-10 lbs..he was large. We had him for several years but never were able to get any hens to go with him to raise anymore unfortunately.
Because of seeing such a beautiful bird I was smitten by the Houdans and in later years when I was able to have some chickens of my own I bought some from a hatchery. What a disappointment! They had been bastardized by the hatchery into some mongrel of polish and Houdan. Most didnt have 5 toes and none of them had good mottling in any way shape or form. They were all the size of polish, much lighter than what my Houdan had been. They were flighty and skittish like Polish not easy going and mild like my true Houdan had been.
I have no idea where the Houdans I obtained came from but they were extraordinary. My dad talks about an old woman in the small little town he grew up in who had a large utility flock of Mottled Houdans that she kept next to the house of about 50 -75 birds. He talked about how they all looked like the Cock bird we had raised. What an extraordinary sight that would be to see that many quality birds now!
Entirely opinion here but for all the good that hatcheries do in allowing easy access to birds of wide varieties, they do a real disservice to the breeds themselves by their lack of knowledge or just flat not caring about raising proper representations of these varieties. And yes, I realize they are in business to make money but just think how successful they would be and how many more customers they might have if they bred their stock to be a little more true to type that what they do. Just an observation.
Someday I too would like to delve back into the world of Houdans and reproduce the bird of my memory. IF you want the size you are going to have to breed with Dorkings, if you want the color and mottling like that you will have to cross with either Anconas or Javas to improve their mottling. If you want it all in a Houdan, you are going to have to set up most likely three different breeding pens with combinations of all three varieties to improve those traits. And this isnt even talking about increasing crest size to where it should be either. A daunting task to say the least for an ambitious fancier.
Great talking about Houdans and good luck with such a great breed.