I'm so glad to hear you "crazy chicken people" acting like my crazy chicken self. I'm joining late in this thread because I JUST found you guys. I had my first experience recently that I'll share. I had two Buff O's go broody at the same time, so I quickly ordered some eggs from BYC that were shipped to me and arrived in 3 days all nicely wrapped. So I moved one broody to a secure pen-like large cage and placed the 12 eggs in a nice nest box inside. By the next morning she still hadn't laid on them but had messed around w them. So I went and got the other broody and she wouldn't lay on them either!! By then, I was super anxious and obsessed. I had just paid for a variety of really cool eggs and these hens were not cooperating. The first broody had already gone back to her normal nest box and was still being broody, so I took the eggs up to her and slipped them under her. I let the other broody go and when she went back to being broody, I divided the eggs thinking I was bettering my chances by using both of them. I started candling on day 8 and not knowing exactly what I was doing, I was unsure of what I was seeing. More obsession here, lol. A couple of the eggs were Marans and very dark to see. To not ramble on much longer, it ended up ALL were duds!@#&. 4 quitters and and 8 nothings. Talk about discouraging!!!!
Well after all that I wanted baby chicks!!! So now I'm on day 3 with one of the same broodies with my own eggs. Yes, I had fertile (I hope) eggs myself, but just wanted some new pure breeds to add to my flock. I have a New Hampshire roo (Randy) so I placed 8 eggs under my broody. 1 white leghorn, 1 red sex link, 3 EE, and 3 Buff O. These will be what everyone is calling "barnyard mixes."
I tell you, I have learned sooo much from BYC. I was able to view videos, egg progression charts, and read enough good advice to figure out what was going on with my dud eggs, so at least I never had a rotten egg blow up on me, haha. I'm hoping I'll have some luck with these 8 eggs.