Best Breed for....(a kinda, sorta, poll)

Discussion in 'General breed discussions & FAQ' started by Merrymouse, Apr 19, 2018.

  1. Merrymouse

    Merrymouse Songster

    Jan 8, 2017
    I thought it might be helpful for new chicken peeps to have a thread they can refer to for opinions on different breed characteristics and what other chicken folks have found out about their different breeds that they have in their flocks....does that make sense? :idunno

    Maybe we could list for example:
    Friendliest chicken
    Most skittish chicken
    Best layer
    Worst layer
    Largest egg
    Smallest egg
    Prettiest egg
    Top of pecking order
    Bottom of pecking order
    Smallest chicken
    Largest chicken
    Favorite chicken
    Least favorite chicken although I think most of us will have a hard time with this
    Or maybe say which chickens you would definitely have again or ones you would not likely get again..
    or any other attribute and/or fault
    This way people can get a sense of what having that particular chicken would be like. Or see if maybe their chicken doesn't fall in line with the typical say "barred rock" or example.
    Please try to format in the same way in each post so its easy for people to compare and scroll through post with maybe a little blurb at the end about your flock....

    Ok GO!.....I'll start
    KDOGG331 and HuskerHens18 like this.
  2. Merrymouse

    Merrymouse Songster

    Jan 8, 2017
    Friendliest chicken=Barred Rock
    Most skittish chicken=FBCM
    Best layer=all of my rocks (Barred, Silver Penciled, Buff)
    Worst layer=Welsummer
    Largest egg=FBCM
    Smallest egg=Cream Legbar
    Prettiest egg=Silver Penciled Rock/light pink opalescent beautiful
    Top of pecking order=FBCM
    Bottom of pecking order=Silver Penciled Rock
    Smallest chicken=Cream Legbar
    Largest chicken=FBCM
    Favorite chicken=barred rock/silver penciled rock
    Least favorite chicken although I think most of us will have a hard time with this=probably Welsummer

    I have a mixed flock of 6 hens. I know you all thought I was going to say prettiest egg should be FBCM and although she lays very pretty dark chocolate and she is stunning and big and gorgeous to look at I really love the opalescent light pink of my Silver Penciled the best.
    I have 7 new chickie babies and none of the same breeds of my other flock so Ill update as these grow up....

    Thanks for playing along all:clap
  3. LilJoe

    LilJoe Crowing

    Jul 15, 2016
    Best layer: Cream Legbar Cross
    Worst layer: FBCM (only because she lays really dark eggs)
    Largest egg: Cream Legbar Cross
    Smallest egg: Orpington and/or Cream Legbar
    Prettiest egg: FBCM
    Top of pecking order: I have two flocks so.. Flock #1: Cream Legbar. Flock #2: Cream Legbar Cross
    Bottom of pecking order: Flock #1: Cochin (used to be top before molt) Flock #2: FBCM
    Smallest chicken: Cream Legbar
    Largest chicken: Cream Legbar Cross

    (I will not play favorites today ;) )
    HuskerHens18 and Merrymouse like this.
  4. BantyChooks

    BantyChooks Pullarius

    Aug 1, 2015
    My Coop
    In general, things like temperament are very loosely correlated with breed. More depends on their environment. So, I wouldn't take any of this as a defining thing behind breed selection, only as an opinion based off my extremely small bird sets. Yes, there are some lines with distinct tendencies, but the overwhelming majority of birds are just chickens and make good backyard birds for most people. "The plural of anecdote is not data."

    Friendliest chicken: Naturally friendliest? An EE x Sultan mutt. I barely handled her as a pullet and she still climbs on my lap at every opportunity.

    Most skittish chicken: Currently a Dominique cock. This depends mostly on handling... I've never met a bird yet that I couldn't tame if I wanted to put the time in. I've had a bunch of other skittish birds but I can't recall breeds. I've had about 200 chickens so my memory isn't perfect on everything. Leghorns can be pretty jumpy if you don't raise them yourself.

    Best layer: White Leghorn, far and away. I've been getting an egg a day from those lovelies through almost the entire winter.

    Worst layer: Hmm, I'd say my Welsummer Olive Egger, a designer mutt type of breed. She hasn't given me over an egg a week since last summer. She's about two years old.

    Largest egg: That's an age thing, but my sexlinks gave me the most consistently largest. They couldn't fit in the cartons. :barnie

    Smallest egg: OEGBs, but no surprise there.

    Prettiest egg: Shell colour? My Ameraucanas lay a nice blue, and the above mentioned olive egger has pretty eggs when she gets around to presenting me one. I don't own any breeds that lay a dark brown egg. Cayuga ducks lay neat black eggs for the first part of their laying cycle.

    Top of pecking order: I don't know. I seem to have more of a rotating pecking order. Perhaps because I have a steady stream of birds going in and out of the flock.

    Bottom of pecking order: Again, I don't know. Perhaps the EE x Sultan mentioned in the first question.

    Smallest chicken: OEGB. I think one of my hens clocks in at about a pound and a half. Can't go smaller without sacrificing cold tolerance.

    Largest chicken: Partridge Chantecler or Australorp.

    Favorite chicken: Breed? Partridge Chantecler, for their colour, productivity, cold hardiness, size, docility; Silver Ameraucana, for their plumage and egg colours, hardiness, and body type; and White Leghorns, for their incredible rate of lay, feed to egg conversion, cold hardiness, range wariness, and intelligence. I'd highly recommend White Leghorns for a free-range backyard flock focused on egg production in a more southern climate, i.e. anywhere south of Toronto without temperatures much below -10F. in winter Even the hens get frostbite when temperatures are below zero F for weeks on end, which is their flaw. They're cold hardy in all other respects, though, and not prone at all to falling over dead because the winters are 'too much'. I've only owned about 10 so far, though. Favourite individual? Spangled OEGB, a spoilt rotten 3-year-old hen.

    Least favorite chicken: Sexlinks. Can't stand them. They have Leghorn-like personalities only on overdrive, they eat a lot, they die young. Plus they're plain in colour. Would not recommend unless you're looking to keep birds for one to two years only and buy replacements from a feed store instead of breeding. They were created for a specific purpose, and if that happens to be the purpose you want them for, fine—that's just not what my flock goal is. I've tried about 20 different breeds—more if you count mixes or varieties—and they all had their flaws, or reasons they didn't fit my flock. I found what I wanted in the PCs and Silver AMs.
    As a note I hear some of the same complaints about Leghorns, the hatchery White variety in particular. They are a bit on the pecky side of things but they haven't made me bleed like the red sexlinks have. Little cannibals, they are.

    I have a flock of about 40 birds at the moment, counting ducks and quail. 10 Silver Ameraucanas, 5 Partridge Chanteclers, 5 quail, 9 ducks, 4 White Leghorns, 3 bantams, and a bunch of other breeds and mutts that I can't recall at the moment. I keep birds for eggs and breeding to the Standard of Perfection. Bug control is a plus. Their meat tastes fantastic but it's not a main reason I have them right now. Quail are pets, ducks are pets and eggs.
  5. Blue Eager

    Blue Eager Songster

    Oct 30, 2017
    South of Albuquerque, NM
    Wow a rookie already benefiting from this thread. I keep getting a pink egg from my dedicated layers. She doesn’t lay all that often so I haven’t been able to identify her. Now I know (I think) there is actually a breed that lays this gorgeous pink egg. I will take some pix & maybe someone here can help me id her.

    Merrymouse likes this.
  6. varidgerunner

    varidgerunner Songster

    Aug 16, 2013
    Smartest, friendliest, top of the pecking order, longest lived, best mother, oldest breed, worst layer, all one breed, the Asil. They will be your most or least favorite. Sorry, shameless breed plug over.
  7. Merrymouse

    Merrymouse Songster

    Jan 8, 2017
    Ill try to get a picture of my pink egg. Very hard to get a true color from my phone camera. You really cannot see the shimmer of the pink. Pink in my hand and in the middle for comparison. Not really showing the color well. k

    Attached Files:

    Clucking_Crazy and BantyChooks like this.
  8. Merrymouse

    Merrymouse Songster

    Jan 8, 2017
    See this is very helpful...I never even heard of these chickens but Im going to go look them up now! Thanks
    BantyChooks likes this.
  9. Merrymouse

    Merrymouse Songster

    Jan 8, 2017
    Another I have never heard of....checking them out..thanks
  10. Merrymouse

    Merrymouse Songster

    Jan 8, 2017
    731DBFE3-07C1-4533-8FE4-1BDE95F65B1B.jpeg B3EB346A-C943-4D13-9AF4-345581163F8B.png @Blue Eager here is a picture of my silver penciled that lays pink. Do you have one that looks like this in your flock? She is a variety of rock so maybe you have a rock in your flock. I’m no expert just a beginner too but thought this might help you.
    JedJackson likes this.

BackYard Chickens is proudly sponsored by: