They still look pretty young and will probably get more color so I would give them a little longer but number 4 is definitly a no go.Not the greatest pictures but you can kinda see what I have to work with..... Although, I don't plan on breeding for more than myself, and I only have 2 BCM pullets, the rest will be EE's and G.Comets. I do want to keep the best looking one!
#1
^ This one was my pick because he has the slate colored legs, decent leg feathering and the least amount of red/gold leakage on his wings.
Lots of leakage on this boy I think? #2
#3
#'s 1 2 and 3
#4 with Yellow legs He is a few weeks younger than the others.
#4 in the back....