Blue Andalusian roosters?

[9d84runner]

I have 2 Blue Andalusian chickens. I thought they were both roosters but when I posted a picture of them for sale, I had 5 different people tell me 1 was a hen and 1 was a rooster. However they both crow. One sounds a little different but they both crow... I've heard of hens crowing but they also look the same with the comb and wattles. I'm new to this breed so please help! I've posted a picture. The darker was is the roo and the lighter with only the tail showing is the "hen".

 

[Brahma Chicken5000]

I have 2 Blue Andalusian chickens. I thought they were both roosters but when I posted a picture of them for sale, I had 5 different people tell me 1 was a hen and 1 was a rooster. However they both crow. One sounds a little different but they both crow... I've heard of hens crowing but they also look the same with the comb and wattles. I'm new to this breed so please help! I've posted a picture. The darker was is the roo and the lighter with only the tail showing is the "hen".View attachment 1260681

The darker one is definitely a cockerel. If they both crow and you’ve seen both crow then they are both likely cockerels. Can you post a full body picture of the lighter Andalusian?

 

[RoostersAreAwesome]

How old are they? It's strange that they're still not showing male saddle feathers...

 

[JedJackson]

The one in front is definitely a male and I do see saddle feathers. I couldn't say about the other one without a better picture of it.

 

[Brahma Chicken5000]

I can clearly see pointed saddles feathers on the Andalusian in the front of the picture.

 

[PlymouthRockBBredSebright]

I need a picture of the "hens" hackle feathers. (feathers around neck) please

 

[PlymouthRockBBredSebright]

Back one is most likely a hen. Notice the rounded saddle feathers on her.

 

[9d84runner]

Just took these pictures. So hard taking a picture of them. I don't see any roundness to the tail feathers. However I am not a chicken expert. I hope these are better.

 

[Brahma Chicken5000]

Just took these pictures. So hard taking a picture of them. I don't see any roundness to the tail feathers. However I am not a chicken expert. I hope these are better.

They both look like cockerels. How old are they?

 

[PlymouthRockBBredSebright]

Both look like Cockerels