I understand how you and dan feel. I have been there. BUT, these threads are here to help us better the quality of chicken breeds. If nobody cared or knew about what makes a certain breed of chicken what it is, then we would all end up with barnyard mixes! I appreciate those "divas" as you put it because they know the standards for BLRW and I value their opinions. I would love to have a BLRW as beautiful as their birds. And I have seen many people post photos of birds that are suppose to be BLRW and they look nothing like what they should. Dan, I think your hen is lovely. The roo does have orangy coloring (at least that photo and the computer makes it look like it), but he is yours and I know you are proud of him. People here are not trying to be rude, they are responding truthfully to your asked opinion! Many people on this thread are very qualified to give you a correct opinion of your birds. If you took your birds to a poultry show to be judged, and they said the same thing that the "divas" said, would you be mad or think those judges were rude? No, you would probably look for a better chicken. This is all these people are trying to do....show you what is good and what is bad about the chickens we have. Maybe you could send another photo of your roo in better light so we can see him better.
All that being said, that is why I love Easter Eggers! They can look like whatever they grow up to look like because there are NO Standards to live up to!
It is evident that Flowerbh understands people as well as she understands chickens. A very well written and thoughtful response. I got into chickens as a hobby after I had to retire. At first I just wanted some pretty ones and some eggs. The Wyandottes, not the BLRW, were recommended to me by friends who had a rooster that came up on their porch and had coffee out of a saucer with them every morning. Being a novice, I looked at the types and settled on the BLRW chickens. I bought eggs from someone who said they came from a well recognized line. I looked on the internet at their pictures and liked them. Well, mine do not look like the ones one the site. They are pretty to me and I enjoy them, but decided to learn more about them and put mine on here to get comments. Didn't go well. But it was what I wanted to learn. I appreciate the comments and am turning from wanting backyard chickens to better backyard chickens. While some of the responders may be blunt sounding, I believe it is because of their expertise and desire to improve the line. I even pestered one poor lady with private messages and she finally stopped replying. But I am thankful for her imput and directions. As a result of the critique I have found a place with birds that are a work in progress, but much better birds quality wise than I have. Sometimes when our enthusiasm gets dampened by others we tend to withdraw. Hopefully those that are offended will not and maybe one day I can get some good birds from you. And blunt or not, when I put my pictures on from my better birds months down the road, I hope to get the same honest and straightforward critique. Not all artist come from the gallery with a smile after the show. Oh, and thanks Flowerbh, you inspired and uplifted me as well!