The package I ordered from an ebay seller, had I disputed it, would have shown as tracking right to my mailbox as well, but it never arrived physically, only according to tracking. BUT I know that is the fault of the post office and not the seller, therefore I took the loss. I obviously couldn't leave feedback for the seller on the item, as I never recieved it, but it wasn't their fault my mail carrier can't deliver right. That was awful that they would blame you when it showed that it arrived at the post office.It absolutely is not the seller's fault that the Post Office damaged the box. Buying shipped eggs is always a risk. Frankly, I think it was petty of you to open a dispute with this seller just because they didn't apologize for the post office's poor handling of the eggs. If you win, the seller will lose the income from the eggs and the shipping cost. That's just wrong, in my opinion. We sell things on ebay and we had one buyer who claimed they didn't get their package. We called the post office, checked the tracking number and found out that the package was tracked right to that person's mailbox. Didn't matter. We lost the dispute, so not only were we out what we paid for the item, we were also out the shipping and the income. People like that give ebay a bad name. Maybe next time you want to try hatching eggs, you should look for them locally and drive to pick them up. Just realize that most of the time, you don't get a 100% hatch, so please don't go after the poor person you bought them from if some don't hatch.