I have never had this problem with the brahmas I have had, but that has been very few. I had more of a problem of that with my EEs. I let them sleep outside and survived through the harsh winter in a bush, I tried the whole shove in the coop may times, but what can I say they are rebels. To me it doesn't seem like an overly big deal, but now all mine go in the barn. Unless you really do not like this habit I wouldn't send him to the pot. It is hard to prove that he is the root of the problem. Must of my hens could care less about the rooster and just do what they want, and the roosters follow. It is hard to tell what is going on in their bird brainsWell, seems like I go offline for a day and the boards light up! Now, can someone please tell me why my brahmas are my only chickens that won't go into the coop for bed every night? Everyone else goes into their respective coops, but every night I have to go out and move the brahmas into the coop. It's not hard, I just pick them up one by one and give them a little shove on the fluffy butt when I put them down facing the door. I suspect it is because the cockerel doesn't go into the coop at night (they all go in during the day to lay their eggs) and as their leader, they feel like they should stay out with him. Should I put him in the pot and get a new cockerel since he doesn't have the sense to protect his girls inside the house at night?