Breed Suggestions?

Discussion in 'Managing Your Flock' started by nugget2000, Jan 10, 2016.

  1. nugget2000

    nugget2000 Out Of The Brooder

    Jul 18, 2015

    I currently have 3 BOs, 2 Jersey Giants, and 1 Copper Maran, and I'm thinking of maybe getting some fertilized eggs for when one of them goes broody. 2 of my BOs and my JGs will turn one in April, and I'm guessing one of them might go broody in the spring. However, I'm struggling to find a good breed for my flock. I want some good layers like my BOs (they lay about 5-6 a week, each), but less noisy. Lots of people say BOs are quiet, but mine aren't [​IMG]. So I know it really depends on the chicken, not so much the breed, but it would be nice to get some with a quiet reputation. It is also important for them to be docile, and cold hardy as well (be able to survive up to about -5 degrees celsius). Suggestions?

  2. GodofPecking

    GodofPecking Chillin' With My Peeps

    Dec 16, 2015
    do you have some kf's or tj's yet ? what about those vf's I hear they're good. Sorry, yes I'm making up annoying abbreviations. Please don't abbreviate on the first mention of the breed so I know what you mean.

    GET POLISH !!!

    Yeah, polish are cool. my polish got compliments from a visitor just today. They are too hysterical.
  3. N F C

    N F C just 1 more cup pls Premium Member Project Manager

    Dec 12, 2013
    Probably the quietest girls I have in my mixed flock are the red sex links and the Speckled Sussex. The SS are the more docile of the 2 in my experience but the RSL's will out-lay them.
  4. Egghead_Jr

    Egghead_Jr Overrun With Chickens

    Oct 16, 2010
    NEK, VT
    Any breed you choose will be fine, there are hundreds of chicken breed and you'll get almost that many suggestions.

    Why I'm writing is to caution you of counting your chickens before they hatch. If you've hatchery stock birds now it is unlikely any of them will go broody this spring. Then again if you get an incubator to hatch your eggs half your flock will go broody. Though with hatchery birds that's not going to happen. The point is you need a local source that you can obtain eggs on a few days notice IF one of your birds goes broody. That's going to narrow your choices right there. If you hold out for the birds to be ready you'll likely not have chicks this year.
  5. Chicken Egg 17

    Chicken Egg 17 Chillin' With My Peeps

    Dec 11, 2015
    McVeytown PA

    My americanua sivler penciled rock and barred rorck mix are the most noisest chickens i have i have four of them and and 4 rhode island red and a rooster i dont know what he is he just show up at are house a year ago and would sit on are railing on the porch so we caught him and got him some hens i like the rhode island reds they are the quiet ones of the flock
  6. dlp40

    dlp40 Chillin' With My Peeps

    Dec 1, 2015
    Florence sc
    I have 6 breeds/mixes, olive egger, blk Sexlink, barred rock, wht leghorn, Easter egger, and a buff orp. Both of the "eggers are always talking/squaking. Wht leghorn would be next with the barred rock and buff coming in 4th and 5th. So my blk sex link is super quiet. She hardly talks at all. She has a deep sounding egg song as well vs all the high pitched ear piercing songs of my others.
    So, blk Sexlinks are quite BUT, mine is terrible to try and add to the flock with. She chases new members around and around the yard and when she cayches them, she shakes them like a dog with a toy! Yep shes my little meany. So no new birds for me unless they live in different coops and runs. Barely hear a peep out of the B hole though[​IMG] and she lays great.
    Have fun choosing.
  7. rebrascora

    rebrascora Overrun With Chickens

    Feb 14, 2014
    Consett Co.Durham. UK
    Egghead_Jr is right. There is no guarantee that any of your hens will go broody, so your best option is probably to enquire locally for eggs if that situation occurs. Also shipped eggs are less successful, so that's another reason to find some locally. Broodiness has been bred out of most hens these days as the majority of people want them to produce the maximum number of eggs possible. If you had a silkie or cochin in your flock, then that would greatly increase the likelihood of having a hen go broody.

    The other thing to consider is what you plan to do with the cockerels that will almost certainly result from hatching fertile eggs. If you plan to raise them to eat, then you are best looking for hatching eggs from a dual purpose breed. If you are not going to eat them then it's a good idea to have a plan regarding what you are going to do with them before you start.... They grow up remarkably quickly and start to make a nuisance of themselves before you know it, both from a crowing point of view but also harassing your hens. The vast majority of people who find themselves with roosters are looking to rehome them and there isn't a fairytale ending for most of them, much as people like to kid themselves there is.

    Since you are looking for good layers I would respectfully suggest that Polish are not the breed for you. I too would highly recommend sex links both for character and egg production. I particularly like black sex links although for some reason I don't seem to have any in my flock at the moment. As regards being noisy, I think it comes down to the individual although I find my welsummers quite quiet in general, but I think that may be more to do with the strain than breed.
  8. song of joy

    song of joy Chillin' With My Peeps

    Apr 22, 2012
    Central Pennsylvania
    I agree - hatchery birds are a gamble when it comes to broodiness. My hatchery BO was a great setter, but this homicidal hen killed the chicks when they hatched.

    If one of your hens goes broody, I'd recommend local hatching eggs. If you're in or near a rural area, you may be able to find someone who keeps a rooster(s) with their flock of laying hens, and who sells eggs for eating and/or hatching. It's best if these eggs are fresh (only a day or two old) and haven't been refrigerated. I bought eggs like these from a neighbor and my broody olive egger hatched out 6 chicks. Most were mixed-breed, but I consider that a plus as they should be hardy and more likely to go broody than hatchery birds. In this case, the barnyard flock included black australorp, Rhode Island red, leghorn, barred rock and easter egger, all of which are good egg layers.

    Based on personal experience, I wouldn't give shipped or expensive hatching eggs to an unproven broody. Shipped eggs are a huge gamble (see other threads).

    For quiet breeds that are good egg layers, go broody, and tend to be good mothers, I'd highly recommend black australorp. You may also have good luck with mixed-breed hens going broody.
  9. Ridgerunner

    Ridgerunner True BYC Addict

    Feb 2, 2009
    Northwest Arkansas
    I pretty much agree with what most people are saying. I’ve had good luck with hatchery broodies but not always with the “broody” breeds. To me strain is more important than breed for everything from going broody to how they lay to how noisy they are. It doesn’t have to be a breed unless you just want a breed. A flock of barnyard mixed-breed mutts may suit you very well.

    I don’t know where you are, but what I suggest is that you find your state or (since you are using Celsius instead of Fahrenheit) probably country thread in the “Where am I? Where are you!” section and chat with your neighbors within driving distance. Tell them what you want and see if any of them can help.

    Good luck!
  10. GodofPecking

    GodofPecking Chillin' With My Peeps

    Dec 16, 2015
    I can also recommend the 'mixed mutts' as I've had success there, a friend gave me some eggs to 'test' his rooster is doing it's job and I got 6 out of maybe 7 that hatched and seem very healthy in their 2nd week. Also, my first ever hatched out chicks, a pair of girls, are very very sweet and quiet and calm and lay eggs very well. You can expect whatever you raise yourself to be calm and quiet and that they'll like you.

    Btw, my polish recommendation, for people who were not following the thread is in addition to nugget's 6 existing chooks, so laying is not relevant. Looks are worth it alone.

BackYard Chickens is proudly sponsored by