I'm inclined to agree with you to a certain point but IMHO, the ideal situation is to have a qualified mentor and that's what I'm banking on. Alone, I wouldn't know which way is up and I'm not too proud to ask for help.I think it is not as easy to mess them up when you hold on to your originals. If you get a Buckeye person to help you pick your keepers from the first batch, and hold on to the keepers for a few years, you will not have gotten any worse off than your start. You can get a feel for it by then. A few generations of watching them grow out and mature, and getting their standard in your head is all it takes.
A beginner can be helped by flock mating. There is more variability, and therefore more room for error.
