It's true, I can find good white Chanteclers and I do consider them to be an excellent breed as well. From what I understand about Chanteclers they are probably better egg layers than the Buckeyes too. But our weather is more like Ohio than La Belle Provence, and the comb and wattles need to be a bit bigger for effective summertime cooling here.
I prefer the look of the Buckeye too, I love the big brows and Brahma-like skull, and I like the pea comb much more than the walnut. So it's just a matter of preference. I would probably like Chanteclers more if they didn't remind me too much of Headless Mike
Not enough mass above the neck on a Chantecler, pour moi!
But, one day, I will probably own some Chanteclers, I do admire that breed and I absolutely love the tails on the roosters.