Well, I guess everything was too good to be true. My 2 broodies hatched out 5 chicks, & then yesterday I gave them the 3 chicks we hatched in the incubator and everything seemed fine. This morning, though, I woke up & heard some upset cheeping from the broody coop. I opened the door & 2 of the incubator chicks were away from the hens & all the other chicks.
I moved them over to the hens, and one of the hens started attacking the yellow chick. I moved it away form her but she started attacking it again a few minutes later. The same thing happened 3 times so I decided to move him inside.
The yellow chick is a bright color that stands out from all the other chicks, so I guess the broody realized he wasn't hers. I brought in one of the other chicks to keep yellow company.
My husband wants to try putting the yellow chick back with the hens again tonight, but I think it's a lost cause. Any ideas?