The bumblefoot that I just treated had a core of an infected mass that was the size of two small peanuts. Soaking would not have done a thing to rid the chicken of this. Lancing only works if all there is is pus in the foot. Yes, I pulled off the "scab" and pulled out the mass without anesthesia. The hen was calm in my arms. She flinched only once. It was less stressful for her than a trip to a vet and anesthesia. I cleaned her foot again today and she is walking without any hesitation on it. She is eating, drinking and behaving normally.