Well if you're willing to do a little bit of upgrades to it, it might be ok for you. Im pretty anal about my chicken coop because the one I built is pretty nice, it doesnt leak, its warm and SOLID. It also took a lot of work, which is why I didnt want to build another one. But with all of the upgrades Im doing Im wondering if I would have been better off just building my own. Where you live is something to consider, whats the weather like in the winter time where you live? It can get pretty cold here and I tested this coop by just letting the hose rain down on it, nothing major, just a sprinkle and I ended up with a lot of water inside, mostly thru the nesting box roof. Its not a big deal to put some composition roofing on the outside of it in some places. Predators is something to think about too. Racoons are pretttyconsistent and I definitely dont trust the latches that came with this coop, but its not a big deal to put better ones on. I guess it would be ok for a starter coop depeding on where you live and what your conditions are, you have plenty of time to weatherize it and customize it before winter comes, which is I think is bogus that you have to do, but even a little bit of caulking would help it too. I think they still have free shipping, which is a big deal. Its really easy to put together, that was kind of cool. It doesnt come with a run tho like the other coop and I think 6 full size chickens would be a stretch. I think 4 would be the most I would want to put in there, unless you get bantams. The other coop you're looking at seems pretty cool too. But thats what I thought about this one. I dont know if I will buy anymore prebuilt coops, tho these Amish ones are VERY well built, but they're pretty expensive. But I would have rather paid a little more money and had more of a solid coop. I wouldnt buy another one of these let me it that way. If it was me and I had known about all of these problems, which in my opinion shouldnt even be there after spending almost 500 bucks, I wouldnt have purchased it. I mean COME ON! What were these guys thinking? Its a chicken coop and its going to be OUTSIDE and SHOULD not LEAK!!! Being easy to clean is HUGE too, I learned that one after I built my first chicken run. The next one I built I made it so the whole entire top opens up so I dont have to crawl inside an my hands and knees to clean it out. Here is the one I built.
https://www.backyardchickens.com/a/the-peach-parlor. The slide out tray in the Bungalow is VERY COOL, I built one into the coop I built. So like I said, I wouldnt have bought it if I could have seen it hands on first, but if you're creative and willing to spend a little bit of time, I guess it would be an ok coop for you. Theres a TON of chicken coops out there so make sure you look around,
Amazon has a bunch too., Did you read the whole thread? There was some dog houses at the Tractor store that could easily be converted into a chiciken coop that were NICE and I could have easily put 4 of them together had a coop 4 times bigger for less money. Anyway, hope this helps!