I purchased 3 ameraucana chickens last year.  They started laying blue and green eggs.  So I would estimate that I've regularly  gotten these colored eggs for about 8 months now.  A month or so ago I thought they stopped laying for some reason.  Today I was lucky enough to watch one lay an egg.  The egg was cream colored.   So now I'm wondering if they are actually laying eggs, but are now a different color.  Is it normal for a chickens egg color to change?  I always thought that what ever color they lay is what it will always be.  Is it something I'm doing wrong?  Everyone told me before I started with chickens that it was easy to keep a flock, but my chickens have given me a run for my money since day one.  I keep them fed, they have a large enclosed run for a semi free ranging feel (bad flying predator area), the always have plenty of fresh water, just always done everything I could to keep them happy.  And keeping them laying has always been difficult.  Now this egg color change has knocked me for a loop.  I have a flock of 24 including 2 roosters.  Currently getting 2 to 5 eggs daily.