I'm in Missouri so the predators would be foxes, possums, raccoons, coyotes, dogs, hawks, owls and bobcats. I think that covers everything that I Know are in my immediate area.
I do think a coyote would have packed him off - unless my dog interrupted him or Cain managed to get out of his reach.
The saddest part is that Cain was a playmate to my house dog and would roll over to play with her. I'm not sure if he would roll over to play with a strange dog or a wild animal.
Right now I can't find one of my other cats and I haven't seen him all day. The one I'm missing hangs out with the one that was killed. Of course I am talking about a cat and they don't always come when you call them...
I've decided to leave poor Cain by the chicken house tonight. He is wrapped up and I feel very morbid about it. However, I'm thinking a coyote or other wild animal would come back for him - while a dog would not.
Kittymomma thanks for the offer but you are a long drive away from me
I have (hopefully) six other cats. They have all been strays or dumpees I've taken in over the years. I found Cain and his brother Abel at a local (Abels) gas station last year. Cain growled at me when I picked him up - hence the name Cain and Abel. His brother is the one MIA.
I am leaning towards a neighbors dog, I'm going to see about rigging up a camera to the outside of my chicken house. I'm pretty sure whatever it is will be back....