I've had great luck with cat food, not so much with the rest. Tonight though I'm trying some of the other things.
let me clearify. Let it out of ur "live trap" and then shoot it with shot gun on the run. WIth bird shot, i hardly even see blood come out of them. U dont even see holes in them they are just, well dead.
as for conibear defintly put it where nothing else will get into it! as the feller said. Neighbors cat. You dont want that. Not a pretty sight.
Baits ive used that work great.
Chicken (obviously they tatse good)
Peanut butter
Berries (strawberries/blackberries/blueberries)
Sardines
Corn
I havent had much luck with the marshmellow, i dont know why they dont seem to want it. All my trappin buddies swear by it.