I am posting on this thread because it is the most recent discussion on where to get chicks. I just went through a bad experience - I used to have six hens but due to age I am down to two, only one of which was laying. DH wanted to get more, 4 or 5 more. I could not find pullets (did not want to chance a roo or bother with chicks). We ended up at Blacksmiths due to some "positive" posts on BYC. BAD MOVE!! Two of the pullets we bought there (we got four) had a respiratory illness which did not want to clear after several days of treatment. The other two I bought there seem fine so far. Blacksmiths will not do refunds after two days. Blacksmiths will take them back and treat them, but you loose all rights to the bird - it is a "donation". One had been factory (?) debeaked. I really hated to give her up she was such a sweetie, but I know it was best for my flock. It is interesting that after explaining symptoms to the lady that supposedly treats them, she marked the receipt "donation" and she wrote that the birds were not sick!! They WERE. Both of them.
The thing with Blacksmiths is they have no way to keep wild birds from contact with their birds. It is covered, yes, with chain link which most wild birds go right through. They cannot even tell you what the source was for the bird. It is likely returned birds like mine are thrown right back into the pen with the rest and resold. It is a shame - unsuspecting people like me come along and don't realize what they are buying. All kinds of nasty diseases and it can take out your entire flock in days, and they take no responsibility. I actually saw birds with bare chests, pecked on combs, weepy eyes, ragged feathers. And they are not cheap. $16 for a pullet. Someone posted about Midway City Feed. Next time I'm going to be buying chicks from them, I've been there. If its a roo they will buy it back. IMO Blacksmith's is totally irresponsible and unethical and I will never go back there.