My feedback was based on the SOP - I've studied quite extensively what the SOP calls for in BR's and the birds I got have the above-mentioned faults per the SOP. But - when I was there, he talked a lot about how tasty they are and how he has bred for that. They do have big, deep breasts, which contributes to their quality as a meat bird. And, when I told him what I wanted, he did go to some effort to select decent birds. But - the qualities he was looking for when he selected birds for me were not necessarily the same qualities called for in the SOP and I think that is how he perhaps overlooked the "hump" both of my BR's have in their back that should not be there. The close-set legs are also not desirable because they don't allow optimum space for the reproductive organs. However I'm assuming the birds I got were selected as culls because of the faults I mentioned. I'm not that stressed about it as I do think they have good genetics in there, and will - hopefully produce some better quality offspring, especially when I outcross them to another line of quality BR's. And, they were certainly not the worst of the worst birds in the cull barn!I think Frank knows a ton about breeding. He was very precise when he picked out the older birds for me as far as shape and color and such. Maybe we are too used to seeing these birds that have been bred to produce better egg laying and don't realize how the real item is supposed to look. I wouldn't change anything about my birds from Frank. I haven't looked at the babies to see if there is any gold leakage or not but I think that does just happen now and then. Probably not a show quality thing.
I would consult the SOP to determine what we are looking for. ...
It is strange that they are molting this time of year - did they not go through a molt in late Fall?Morning everyone!
I had forgotten how pathetic hens look when molting. One of my production reds (Nutmeg) is just depressing to look at. All she does is mope around. She is eating and drinking, but just looks quite unhappy. She just got her neck feathers back last week. The tail feathers still haven't come in yet. Poor girl!
Our lagoon is surprisingly full - we can't really figure it out since most of our neighbor's lagoons were bone dry last summer. Ours never did dry up, though I could tell the level got lower, but after the recent precipitation we've had, its quite full. The optimum is for it to be 3' deep, but frankly, I am NOT wading out to the middle of it to measureWhat a good idea! I am surprised your lagoon is full enough for anything to live in! Ours is so low, I added some water about a month ago but it didn't do much good and I didn't really want to run our well dry...
Oh, good to know. I can't imagine a muskrat moving into our lagoon, it is yucky.
What does the SOP for barred rocks say? I would assume leakage would be an immediate cull as it is in most breeds. Even if it doesn't express in the next gen it is still there as far as I understand and will "pop" back up.
I wouldn't beat yourself up too much about getting culls. Keep in mind anytime you buy birds from a breeder you are getting "their" culls. Just because they don't want them doesn't mean they aren't a good start for a breeding project for you. Any good breeder worth their salt wouldn't sell you a pair or trio of birds they didn't think had some prospect if you expressed interest in breeding. If it is a pet quality bird they would tell you right up front like Hawkeye does. That the bird has no place in a breeding program and if the faults are bad enough in the bird they won't even make it to a sale at all. I have butchered birds that I knew I didn't want spreading their genes ever. Usually due to really nasty personalities or a pile of faults that have no place pro creating!

Oh, I'm not beating myself up too much on getting the birds I got - I do think they have the right genetics and it will be fun to work with them to improve them. At the time I was in between trips and didn't want to get chicks that would need special care while I was gone, so I got the older birds, and having them close to laying age is a bonus. As you say, its a gamble getting chicks anyway, because you don't know what you're going to get and have to wait to grow them out to find out. However if we make another trip up there and its a good time to get chicks, I'll probably be in a gambling mood
