Zig I think one of the successes to fermented feed is to mix half and use half every day. Mine took on a very pleasing scent and consistency just using and then adding more feed and water each day. When I stirred I always made sure I stirred while running water and got all the stuff from the bottom well mixed with the new stuff. I wish I had fewer chickens and could still handle all that weight because it was really awesome feed and my birds were so shiny. Another thing I told Trish about in mixing smaller amounts that worked well for me but mixing more than a 5 gallon bucket is to buy a rubbermaid bin. and mix it in that. It's not nearly as messy and easier to stir. You can loosely set the lid on without closing it which keeps nats or flies out and still lets it breath. Sure beats maintaining two buckets.