I'm not going to agree or disagree with either opinion about the diet. Instead I'm probably going to try it both ways. Especially if I dont have any or too few breeding birds come breeding time

. I'll probably start incubating any eggs as soon as i start getting them.... if I get them...
I dont want to step on any toes and appreciate all constructive advice and input. When things go wrong I'll have better chances of fixing the problem now. This is my version of this experiment and I have to make the final decisions. Figuring it out for myself is really the nature of this project. Listening is good but only by testing things will I be able to draw my own conclusions. Its probably going to take several years to hammer this out if i ever do at at all. Having fun with the whole thing already though. I'm probably going to order some more broilers and control their feed way more this next time. Hopefully that will help with the constant use of straw. I've seen youtube videos where broilers fly up to roost like egg layers and know these dieting birds will probably never be able to do that. According to the commercial breeder feed schedule my 10 birds (6 pullets and 4 cockerels) would only require less than 2.5 pounds of feed every other day. I gave them 3 pounds this evening and it certainly didnt look like much at all even just for a single day. I think my egg birds eat more than that. Hope it's not going to cause other problems like fighting, pecking or feather pulling. I know these birds arent generally aggressive but things change when the endless supply of food gets pulled.