I buy/sell/give away on CL all the time. It is my second source for everything I have here on my little farm with the exception of my Delaware flock. Everything else, I get a good bit from CL. I have sold chickens and goats on CL in the last year. It's a great way to trade stock. I have never had an issue with believing the animals are going to a bad home. I haven't replied to any that I would be leary of recieving stock from, or sending stock to. It has been a totally positive experience all around for me in my area. The only way to know is to give it a try. Some CL areas aren't as good as others, but I think a good percentage are good markets to get rid of unwanted stock, and pick up additions to your flock.