Because of your insightful comments, I am changing plans. I am going to take MR.Puny out of the breeding pens and put grandpa Hank back in. I will put Hank's get with Johnny and Hank will get the others. A friend is taking the batch currently incubating with the deal I get up to 4 birds of my choosing back, then he can do as he will with the rest(there are 53 eggs in the incubators, I just pulled the clears). I have 36 chicks in the brooder. Hopefully, the third hatch will yield another 40. Out of that many chickens, I should get a few, better than what I have.
As a side note, Laura, the incubator that has eggs from Johnny(your bird's gene pool) out of 33 eggs there were no clears and 2 questionable quitters. That's virility!!
I have 2 incubators and have only been separating and banding birds per sire not hens. I can trap nest in one pen. How does one keep track during hatching who is whom??
Here's to breeding better buckeyes!!! Thanks folks.