JJ
# 1 by a mile to me. That comb deal is no big thing to fix, it only causes trouble in a show, but for a breeder, he has everything else pretty good in comparison.
He also has a nice point at the rear of the comb and looks to have an excellent wedge shape and spikes to it. He should be a little redder but that's no major issue to me.
number 2 , I just dont like those overly black males. Obvious lacking in the beard dept. Which is way worse that a dip in comb. Also both are a little blurry, but #2's comb doesnt look as well shaped, looks kinda slick ( not many real good spikes to it) and his carriage of his body is a little sloppy. Might just be his neck in comparison, he looks thin built or something.
Both need a little more black in the saddles, but it's hard to find one like that any more.
I'd go with the first one hands down. And to be honest, I'd use him for both projects. Just rotate him out every 3 days and he'll do all the work for you. Especially over some of Art's hens, he should make some fine birds for you. And on a color project, you always want to use the best type to start with. No sense in getting the project complete and then have type issues to have to work out, IF you can avoid it to start with