I just registered so I could post a reply to this thread. I think I have read all the posts over the last few days and most or all of us want the same thing: a humane way to end the life of our chickens. Last Saturday I killed 4 roosters and processed them. It was my first time, but I have been searching the web and talking to people about the best way to do it. I get no enjoyment out of killing flies and other insects, in fact when I find a wasp in the house I pick him up and take him outside. These were my babies that I raised from 1 day old, so the hardest part was the mental preparation. Of course I have spent months trying to find homes for them, and although I found homes for about 6 or 7 roosters, no one wanted Rhode Island Reds. After the mental preparation, I did research. This is how I did it: I picked the rooster up and sat down with it and talked soothingly too it until I could feel it was not scared and trembling. While talking to it I slipped the rope over each of its feet (I had prepared a rope of soft clothesline 3 or 4 feet long with a loop and slip knot at each end. When the slip knot was tight around each foot I held its legs between the fingers of my right hand and supported the body with my left, when I stood up the rooster hung straight down and flailed a few seconds but by supporting his neck and head with my left hand and stroking his head and neck soon it was handing upside down asleep. Then I could use both hand to tie him to a branch of the apple tree where I wanted him to bleed out. I used a scalpel and made 2 cuts one on each side just above the jaw. I truly do not believe that any of them felt pain from the scalpel, (I nicked myself and did not feel it). Then using a small sharp penknife (I had previously sharpened anything I thought I might have to use) opened his beak and it was easy to see a groove in the top which is where to insert the knife and thrust back toward the eyes, then give a little twist, at which point the chicken should make a tiny squawk sound which indicates a successful pithing and of course, death. Reflexes caused the chickens to flail around, at which point you could step back or as we did on the last one, my husband held the wings to the body until the reflexes were finished. That is why I will find something to use as a cone if I ever have to do this again. This was not something I wanted to do but as the person responsible for getting and raising the chickens, I feel that I did the best I could and I am satisfied that they were not frightened or felt any pain using this method. I was able to pluck the feathers by lying the bird on my lap on a towel and did not have to use the bucket of boiling water except for the wings of the RIRs.
In the last few days I have experimented with my other chickens, picking them up and them hanging them upside down holding their feet. At first they flail then within seconds go limp, at which point I can pick lay them in my left arm like a baby on its back. One of my silkies just goes limp for minutes at a time while I stroke his sternum and talk to him. Every one I have tried it on has totally relaxed for varying periods of time. Has anyone else had experience doing this?