Do I have to have a rooster?

[Chickenmama1115]

Do I have to have a rooster for my flock? I am not trying to have chicks. He is stressing my poor girls out because he will not leave them alone. It’s affecting some of them laying. I know it is in their nature, but it just really hurts my soul to see him pull on their necks like that.

 

[MROO]

Do I have to have a rooster for my flock? I am not trying to have chicks. He is stressing my poor girls out because he will not leave them alone. It’s affecting some of them laying. I know it is in their nature, but it just really hurts my soul to see him pull on their necks like that.

You don't need a rooster, especially if you don't free range.

 

[FrostRanger]

You only need a rooster if you want chicks, otherwise it's down to personal preference. Your girls will still lay eggs with or without a rooster

That said, how old are your birds, how many hens do you have and how big is your coop and run? If you do keep your boy, I'd put him in rooster jail for a few weeks so the girls get a break

 

[BlindLemonChicken]

You don’t need a rooster. If you get rid of him a hen will just take over the top spot and get everyone into the coop at night and sort out the pecking order.

 

[Appalachickens]

I only got a rooster for my coop flock because they free-range everyday and we have a lot of hawk activity and one hawk attack. I got an older one so he was a known good boy. Otherwise, I definitely wouldn't have one with them since I don't plan to breed them. (My forest chicken project is another matter - definitely need roosters for that).

 

[Not-so Slick Chicken]

Do I have to have a rooster for my flock? I am not trying to have chicks. He is stressing my poor girls out because he will not leave them alone. It’s affecting some of them laying. I know it is in their nature, but it just really hurts my soul to see him pull on their necks like that.

No, you don't have to have a rooster. Hen-only flocks do just fine.
You may occasionally have a problem pullet/hen, but typically they're fine with enough space and resources.

You also just might not have a very good rooster.

My main rooster is (in my current opinion) great. A bit lazy when the hens are calling for him to check the nest box, but he's relatively gentle with them and always has been. None of the hens or pullets have lost feathers because of him.
Now, the cockerel.... bad bird. The gals started losing feathers when his hormones came in. The exact same birds that had never lost any feathers to the rooster I mentioned.
He got dispatched and nobody misses him, and feathers are already filling in, and they're still with their original rooster.

 

[Ridgerunner]

it just really hurts my soul to see him pull on their necks like that.

First I'll try to ease your soul. The head grab is an essential part of mating. That is the signal for the female to raise her tail so the male can hit the target. If she did not raise her tail there would be no fertile eggs. It is instinctive with chickens. To the chickens, the head grab is not as brutal as you seem to think.

Do I have to have a rooster for my flock?

I agree with the others, you do not have to have a rooster unless you want fertile eggs. Many people strongly believe that you have to have a rooster for flock protection but lots of people have all-female flocks and successfully free range. Lots of people have a rooster and still lose chickens to predators. I have a rooster and have lost a hen to a hawk.

If he bothers you that much get rid of him.

 

[Chickenmama1115]

You only need a rooster if you want chicks, otherwise it's down to personal preference. Your girls will still lay eggs with or without a rooster

That said, how old are your birds, how many hens do you have and how big is your coop and run? If you do keep your boy, I'd put him in rooster jail for a few weeks so the girls get a break

I have 5 girls and then him. I got him and three of my girls at the same time and they were not sexed, so I had no idea that he was a rooster until he got older. My silkie roo, D’uccle and barred rocks are 6 months. My Cochin and silver laced Wyandotte are 2 years old.

I have a pretty decent size coop and run area. He is just young and can’t control himself I guess.

 

[Chickenmama1115]

No, you don't have to have a rooster. Hen-only flocks do just fine.
You may occasionally have a problem pullet/hen, but typically they're fine with enough space and resources.

You also just might not have a very good rooster.

My main rooster is (in my current opinion) great. A bit lazy when the hens are calling for him to check the nest box, but he's relatively gentle with them and always has been. None of the hens or pullets have lost feathers because of him.
Now, the cockerel.... bad bird. The gals started losing feathers when his hormones came in. The exact same birds that had never lost any feathers to the rooster I mentioned.
He got dispatched and nobody misses him, and feathers are already filling in, and they're still with their original rooster.

He’s 6 months and so bad!! He is constantly on their backs and beats their heads to the ground. It breaks my heart. I know it’s a part of it but he pulls feathers at time.

 

[Chickenmama1115]

First I'll try to ease your soul. The head grab is an essential part of mating. That is the signal for the female to raise her tail so the male can hit the target. If she did not raise her tail there would be no fertile eggs. It is instinctive with chickens. To the chickens, the head grab is not as brutal as you seem to think.


I agree with the others, you do not have to have a rooster unless you want fertile eggs. Many people strongly believe that you have to have a rooster for flock protection but lots of people have all-female flocks and successfully free range. Lots of people have a rooster and still lose chickens to predators. I have a rooster and have lost a hen to a hawk.

If he bothers you that much get rid of him.

I know it’s how they breed, I just hate it for my girls. Especially my D’uccle, she’s little bitty. My chicken mama heart doesn’t like to hear any of them squawk.