? dominant roo and subordinate roo - what do you think?

I seem to have exactly the same dilemma. Two silie roos and three hens. They seem to get along now, but others have told me that two roos will exhaust the other birds. We have not done anything yet. They both crow, but not enough to upset the neighbors. We may be expanding and splitting the house this summer when we hatch this spring. I will be looking to see what the experts say.

 

I've never had silkies, but you may need more girls. A good ratio of males to females is 1 to 8-10. My lucky (or worn out) roo has 20 girls, and most of the eggs appear to be fertile.

 

I've never had silkies either, but I do have two roosters and 20 hens. The alpha roo (Silver Gray Dorking) crows all the time. The beta roo (Phoenix) crows like crazy in the coop before the sun comes up, but when he's in the yard, he usually only crows when the SGD isn't around. So basically, he rarely crows outside. Every now and again, he'll fly up to a low branch in a tree and just crow his heart out - and the SGD fusses about it at the base of the tree.

My guess is that your beta roo would crow a lot more if the alpha wasn't around.

 

If you get rid of the first one, I can almost promise you that the second will start crowing. It's something all, if not most, roosters do in their lives, for their group as protection, boasting, etc...

It's a hard choice to make if you love them both. For all you know, the second one may start to be aggressie with the ladies and no longer 'Mr. Nice Guy' anymore, now that he sees he can do whatever he wants. It's all trial and error. Sadly, though, if you get rid of one and can't get him back, you're stuck with the one you chose.

 

I had some doubts about Thor's ability to take charge of my flock when I was contemplating giving away my former alpha Zeus. Thor was very distant from the hens before Zeus' departure and he just acted like he didn't have it in him to be an alpha roo. He very rarely crowed.
A very wise BYC'er reassured me by explaining how Thor was playing politics. He somehow knew that any attempt to take care of the hens or show his manliness in any way would be viewed as an act of aggression by Zeus and Zeus would kick Thor's butt for it.
Thor has really shined as the alpha since I got rid of Zeus. He's so good to the hens and protective of them without being aggressive to humans.
Yesterday I fed them mealworms for the first time. One hundred mealworms and while Thor called the girls repeatedly to come take them he refused to keep one for himself. I'm very proud of him.