Well, keep trying to fiddle with the computer so we can see photos!
So many factors go into which rooster you should keep, tthe body shape is very important (many people say the body shape is most important).
You also want nice legs, the correct color, but also nice and squarely placed under the body, not too close together or knock kneed.
Also the tail angle....
Anyway, lots of things.
If you can post a nice side shot of each male, that would be great. A front shot so that you can see the leg set it helpful, as is a close up of the face/comb/ and wattles.