Duck sitting on nest full of golf balls. Help! (Long post)

Jinglebells0518

Chirping
Jun 25, 2018
84
95
63
So our duck has been laying eggs in her nest over the past week and a half. The last times she laid in this same nest something took her eggs so since it was the same nest in the same spot we decided we would take her eggs in and incubate them.

We've been replacing them with golf balls so she would keep laying and now on egg 9 she has been on her nest all day so far. I'm assuming she has started incubating since she is usually done laying by about 9:30am and today she is still on her nest at 1:30pm.

She likely laid one egg this morning so she is incubating 8 golf balls and the egg I'm assuming she laid this morning. The rest of hers are in our incubator.

Should we let her incubate this egg? I'm worried for many reasons:
1) something just took an infertile egg I put back out there 2 days ago so there is a still a predator watching the nest. I don't want her to be attacked sitting on an egg.
2) the egg will likely still be taken at some point during the 28 days so it would be safer in the incubator.
3) if for some reason she didn't lay this morning or that egg doesn't make it, I don't want her to sit there for 28 days incubating golf balls that she thinks are babies.
4) ducklings have not survived in our area for many years. We have tons of foxes, snakes, turtles, Hawks, and eagles so even if she hatches one, it's survival without human intervention is not likely.

Should I take the egg from her and remove the golf balls so she will stop incubating? We don't really have a good way to separate her and her nest for her to incubate safely that she will have a way to freely leave to get water and food and also the 2 drakes with her are very protective and have been with her for 2 years so I don't know how they would do separated

I feel bad doing this since she's been laying on and off in this nest for 2 months and nothing ever comes of it. But it seems the best outcome for all involved. Should I empty the nest? Do I need to wait for her to leave the nest to take everything? What's the most likely time for her to leave since I know she won't be off the nest often now that she's started. Will this cause her distress? I'm worried to leave her through the night.
 
Move the golf balls to a safe location, the egg to the incubator. If she stops setting, well end of that. If she sets in the new location, at least she can continue safely...
Would she know to look for them? Will she become stressed if her "eggs" all disappear in the 30 minutes she's off the nest?
 
Move the golf balls to a safe location, the egg to the incubator. If she stops setting, well end of that. If she sets in the new location, at least she can continue safely...
Good advice, and I wish my broody ducks were more like my broody chickens. Each time I have tried to move a duck it tries to go back to the original nest. :(
 
Another option would be to build a predator proof nesting box over her. :idunno
Unfortunately the nest is technically on our neighbor's property and she doesn't want any more ducks (we have 10) so she won't condone that. If I were to move her to a safe location would it be somewhere enclosed? She wouldn't be able to use the lake or be with the drakes for a month? Because the first thing she did coming off the nest today was quack really loudly for the drakes she hangs out with. Enclosing her so that it's predator proof would definitely be distressing.

I'm leaning towards taking everything out of the nest and just hoping she realizes she needs a new nesting spot or just stops laying in the nest all together
 
Unfortunately the nest is technically on our neighbor's property and she doesn't want any more ducks (we have 10) so she won't condone that. If I were to move her to a safe location would it be somewhere enclosed? She wouldn't be able to use the lake or be with the drakes for a month? Because the first thing she did coming off the nest today was quack really loudly for the drakes she hangs out with. Enclosing her so that it's predator proof would definitely be distressing.

I'm leaning towards taking everything out of the nest and just hoping she realizes she needs a new nesting spot or just stops laying in the nest all together
Well, you can try that... It might possibly work, though the new nesting spot she picks may be no better, and possibly, even worse. Is there no place on your property that is safe for her, where she can at least see her drake buddies, that would be an ok nest spot? If not, then you need to build one somewhere, and then insist that she use it. You will have to be more stubborn than she is and consistently collect all her eggs and place them in the preferred spot. If it is somewhere where she can at least be enclosed safely at night, with or without her drake buddies, that would be good.
 

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom