Roos are like teenagers, they hit on all the ladys. Both the younger and older ones miss the spot sometimes, even if they get it right they are shooting blanks. And if it is a young hen, she can take up to 3 weeks before she puts out a fertile egg.
In my mutt runs (eating eggs) I have 1 roo for every 15 hens, I could care less if the eggs are fertile.
In my breeding runs, I have 1 roo for 3 hens. In these runs the fertility is 98%, still a miss every once in awhile.
If you are looking to breed a certain breed for show, I would use only chickens that are between 1 and 2 years old. This is when you get the best results. It is not to say that older chickens can't produce quality chicks, just not as often.
Look at it from the human side, would a woman in her prime look to a baby or a man on social security. Either might work but the outcome will not be as good as a 20 to 30 year old man.