Yeah, overthinking it will do that. My first kill didn't go as smoothly as I'd have liked, but I think it was more traumatic for me and DH than it was for the birds. We killed, plucked, and gutted all at once. Once we got the actual dispatching out of the way, I didn't feel as uneasy. That was the worst part for us because we felt that we had let our birds down by not being efficient enough at it. And once we got the heads and feet off (we cut the throat, both DH and I were a little disturbed thinking about decapitation, although we almost had to resort to it as we had a really hard time finding the jugular on two of them) I found it much much easier to deal with because then it was extremely similar to cutting up store bought birds. Except with guts.
Still, I find that "aging" the meat for 24-48 hours not only helps to keep the meat from being tough but also has the advantage of giving me time to distance myself from the actual deed. It took me that long to be totally at ease with handling the carcasses. But by then, cutting them up for parts and putting them in the freezer was easy and just as "normal" to me as doing it with store bought whole chickens with whom I had no relationship. We had the first two this week in chicken tacos and they were the best tacos we've had.
Still, I find that "aging" the meat for 24-48 hours not only helps to keep the meat from being tough but also has the advantage of giving me time to distance myself from the actual deed. It took me that long to be totally at ease with handling the carcasses. But by then, cutting them up for parts and putting them in the freezer was easy and just as "normal" to me as doing it with store bought whole chickens with whom I had no relationship. We had the first two this week in chicken tacos and they were the best tacos we've had.