Bob, your posts make a lot of sense, to me anyhow. I've never fussed with the fancy colored or obscure breeds in 60 years of keeping chickens and have no interest in it now. For those who do, more power to you and best wishes.
I've always had an agricultural bent to my thoughts and my lifestyle. Grew up on farms and homesteads and still live on one. Grew up with Leghorns and Rocks in the 1950's and have seen the landscape change dramatically over the last half century. Back in the day, folks kept Leghorns for fryers and maybe some kept them for eggs as time went along. Most of us kept White Rocks for true dual purpose birds. There were lots of Reds and Barred Rocks around the area. Shoot, I didn't even know about 3/4 of these breeds/varieties we hear of today and only saw bantams at the county fair.
There were no
Tractor Supply Company or other places all holding "Chick Daze". We never heard of a Tera Tint, Cinnamon Queen or any of other hundred hybrid stuff being sold today. They didn't exist.
My interest in "Heritage" birds was renewed five years when I honestly got sick and tired of all these modern birds. To me, they all looked the same. There was a homogeneous look to all of them, just different colors, sort of. In black and white silhouette, you couldn't hardly tell them apart.
I teach young people agriculture and husbandry and began to see that the modern birds were more to agriculture like McDonalds was to food. Neither pleased me. The stuff sold at
TSC or by the modern, internet based hatcheries was McDonalds. I wanted good old fashioned, cooked from scratch the way my grandmother did, birds. Hah!!! Who knew they were virtually extinct? I had to get myself educated so that I could help the young folks I mentor.
Slowly finding out that the true, bona fide, homestead birds of a 50 years ago could still be had was an enlightening experience. It brought a joy, a purpose and a mission to this old man's life. I wish I had the last 30 years to do over. LOL
Now sharing "heritage" birds with all this younger folks, they are stunned and amazed at the difference. They love them. They see their value, their beauty, strength, size, intelligence, calmness, and other traditional personality traits that are sorely lacking in the birds from the feed store that merely pose as those breeds but have very little of the breed's true attributes.
Bob Blosl, YHF, Walt, and so many others have made contribution far beyond the world of competitive showing of birds. The homesteader, those who strive for authenticity in a self sufficient rural lifestyle have bought into these (H) fowl. There is a reason why interest is so high. It was these folks who pushed the Buckeye back from the brink. It is perhaps an off shoot of the competitive show world, but agriculture and small holders was the end result of E B Thompson and Ralph H. Sturgeon breeding in their day too. They sent a lot of great birds to the farm oriented community.
Homesteaders, small holders, and agricultural people, at least the ones I work with, absolutely DO want better birds.