Thank you for the info! What feed are you giving that’s 20% protein? 31 months and have not done their first full molt? I thought they did it much sooner. I just feel bad that she might be like this the whole winter! So many feathers gone.
Most birds do molt way before 31 months.. I fully believe it's the (possibly poor or is it good) genetics causing the delayed molt. It's my first and only time experiencing that in 13+ years of keeping hundreds of fowl and she's also my first and only commercially bred sex link. As other posters have noted.. what we call average or normal seems to vary widely by individual.
I usually use Purina Flock Raiser, but due to rising cost coupled with diminished income, have recently also been using Dumor starter.
Since learning, about a decade ago, that the only or main difference in "layer" is protein (amino acid levels) and calcium % and also that 16% protein (most common layer feeds) is considered the bare minimum to keep light bodied layers like Leghorn in laying condition at a minimum cost and since making the switch.. all of my birds (mostly dual purpose breeds) . enter molt and come through it stronger (much less change in behavior and self isolation) than when I used "layer", as they already have more nutrients on board rather than trying to play catch up once molt has begun. For the industry that rotates their birds out and keeps them under tightly confined and controlled conditions, making $ is their bottom line. For me where weather changes, being able to fight off parasites and having stronger immune systems matters.. and while many flocks do fine and some even have longevity using 16% protein "layer", I definitely notice the difference. Calcium source is always available, free choice.
If you are happy with the 19% protein feed, it's what's available in your location, and your birds seem to like it, I'd not worry about switching.
My opinion and experience coupled with research say that it should be sufficient and also will not cause any harm. Reducing protein or nutrients too far, either by feeding scratch "to keep warm" (myth) or other low nutrient snacks/treats, on the other hand *may* cause more issues including lower immunity, torticollis (commonly called wry neck), and fatty liver hemorhagic disease. Too much
excess protein (WAY more than what's being suggested) or excess calcium fed (to non layers regarding the calcium) LONG term can cause (different types of) gout, kidney failure, and even death.. noting that in these last statements there's almost always a (unseen and unknown) genetic predisposition at play. Many breeder and show formula rations come in at 22% protein.. which was shown in studies I've read to give the highest hatch rates. Plus feathers are made from 90% protein and its amino acids. I once fed 30% protein turkey starter for a period of about 6 months.. it reduced my hatch rates but did not yet even at that level cause any of the conditions noted for excess consumption. Still with anything.. please always do what makes sense to YOU!
If you're worried about her for winter, I'll admit I would probably be uncomfortable for her as well.. and desire more than just the saddle ideas (which are worth considering), maybe
@azygous will share her sweater or other ideas?
Best wishes to you both!
